I've never found animated Belle to be that attractive, and while I think EDR is gorgeous, for some reason I didn't feel that way watching Belle on OUAT (maybe I just don't like her as a brunette, idk). While I do have problems with Emma as an actress, I think she's very beautiful.

I love her looks.

At least, Emille de Ravin has the same- heart-shaped face as the animated Belle. Emma Watson does not resemble her animated counterpart in her facial features at all.

While I don't find Belle very attractive, I still find her more attractive than her live-action counterparts.

The other two are beautiful but very common and ordinary looking. Emma Watson is one of the most beautiful women that ever lived.

I also think that animated Belle is gorgeous too. Emma Watson is perfect though.

Both animated and live action.

Emma Watson is not attractive at all. On top of that, she has even less talent than her lack of looks.