Were tu surprise how harsh Edward was when he broke up with Bella in the New Moon movie?it was different in the book.

actually i think that the book was much harsher and in my opinion i kind of felt sorry for her but later descovered that she was a lying cheating, corazón breaking weirdo who broke poor jacob's corazón the segundo time. dude BELLA WHAT'S THE MATTER WITH tu CHOOSE ONE , EDWARD o JACOB

I actually thought he did it más harshley in the book than movie. Then again, he was harsh in both.

Yes, I agree with OCFan13 (my apologies if I have her screenname wrong). I'd also have to say that he seemed a lot more...cold in the book. In the novel, he was supposedly expressionless and didn't mostrar any emotion in what he was saying. It was exactly like he was 'saying how it is'. That I found a little harsh.

But from what I picked up from the scene in the trailers (I didn't see the movie yet, want to though :D), he looked a little pained and remorseful for what he was saying. He couldn't even look the poor girl in the eye.... :,(

So I think he was más harsh in the movie.


But yet again, I didn't see it! If what I picked up was inaccurate, please describe how he was in detail ^_^
LOL!!

no i wasnt surpirised because i thought it was like the book

he was harsh in both the movie and the book to me...i cried during both.

i think he was harsh in both the book and the movie... i couldnt stop crying through that whole scene especially when she was dreaming and yelling..... it was a great movie, and loved the ending, it kept me wanting for more...