Cinderella is a good movie but it lacks a lot of things. It's mostly filler with thosee stupid mice and cat chases. Plus I don't think they really captured the tragedy of Cinderella's life, it's seems kind of super coded. Up is very entertaining, funny, and adventurous.

This is so hard!

I like Cinderella, but I wish they would of had more scenes that didn't involve the mice,

Me love this movie...

Hm I love both, but Up is such a hilarious movie

It's my fave Pixar movie :)

Love both

Love Cinderella, have no interest in seeing Up.

And a lot more.

Love Carl and Ellie!

I really feel like the only person who can't stand the movie Up, it's definitely the worst Pixar movie to me. Weird thing is, I absolutely loved it the first time I saw it- but each time I've watched it since then I like it *considerably* less than the last time and now I hate it... oh and it's not a case of 'seeing too much of one movie and getting sick of it' because I've seen it less than 5 times. I love the love story between Carl & Ellie and I love Dug, but overall I really hope I never see it again. I'm baffled by the amount of critical acclaim it gets.
Cinderella on the other hand is a wonderful movie.

Not very close for me, but mostly because I just love Cinderella so much.

Not even close for me. Love this movie.