Well, unless Emma is all like "Haha I ruined your happy ending" but she would never do that. Nobody is in the wrong here, really. Regina is wrong to blame Emma in a way but because Emma saved an innocent life and fans are hating on her for that, I'd be tempted to back her up. Especially since I'm loving her again.

I think everyone knows whose side I'm on. I already explained why I disagreed with Emma tampering with both time and life and death. Main rules of time travel; Don't change things. Don't bring back souvenirs. Don't play with life and death. Don't change anything! Do not change the things!!!!! I understand that she was trying to help and didn't want someone to die, but what happened happened and I honestly think it's gonna be a Final Destination type thing anyhow. She had good intent but ended up messing things up for Gina again. I'd be mad too if I finally got something good only to see it blink away before my eyes because someone had tampered with things.

Honestly, I don't think I could really choose a side. Neither are really in the wrong...it's just a bad situation of fate (fate did let Emma go back in time).

I do think it wasn't the smartest thing for Emma to bring Marian back...but who could honestly say they wouldn't do the same...even if they knew who she was? Marian was innocent and going to be killed.

I do hate that the writers are giving us another damn love triangle though.
The only love triangle I want to see is Mulan/Aurora/Philip (with Aurora in the center of the triangle of course)

I wouldn't choose a side on the fight because I love both so much and I'm biased like that :p but well Regina's my fave so I would support her &&& yes Emma shouldn't have changed the past but she did the right thing by saving someone so yeah there's not really wrong and right here ...

I back Emma up completely. People should be less pissy because it's painfully obvious Regina and Robin are endgame, Marian or no Marian. Emma bringing back Marian could potentially resolve a lot of things that were left unsaid between Regina and Robin, like, I don't know, the fact that Regina condemned Robin's beloved wife to death? Now they have a chance to try to fix it. Outlaw Queen shippers should see that as a good sign.

It's hard to say. I understand both.

^^ I can't speak for everyone but I'm more pessimistic about it because now we have another season of Gina suffering. And apparently Gina and Emma are going to be fighting again (which could mess up things with Henry) which is a shame because all 3 were getting along so well. As said above, I'm 99% Marian may die again, 100% OQ will be fine. It's the other things that it effects that worries me.

I'm kind of on both sides for now it depends on what regina does. Honestly I hate that they're regressing her character possibly I think if they take it to far I'm going to loose faith in the show because I'm pretty much watching it for her now.

Agreed @MelodyLaurel!
@Zanhar1 and anone else who has Regina as their favorite, I don't really blame you for picking Regina tbh. If it was Emma vs Ruby I would back up Ruby no matter what. And they actually are going to have a fight? I heard Regina's not going to fight back this time...oh well. Could be interesting. As much as I like them as friends now, nobody can deny they make good enemies.

Guys, it's basically all Rumple's fault to be honest. Had he not killed Zelena, the portal wouldn't have opened. So...congrats Rumple. Look what you've caused :P

I think the\y said it was gonna be a feud like in season 1. Which I think is counter-productive in a 'been there done that' kind of sense.

But yeah, I do pin this one on Rumple above all else.

Regina is smart and strong and admirable, she will solve this problem too I guess. I liked Regina's happiness but don't believe that Robin is the big one. Soulmate or best friend but not the true love, not the happy ending.
Perhaps I am the only one who see the things this way, but I think Rumple is the heart of the show.
Most of cases he's done something to help moving the story forward. Like now: if he wouldn't have been killed Zelena and the portal remains closed, how could have come Elsa through? How would continue the tale?
Yes, Rumple is responsible for what happened and I am grateful to him for the following episodes (seasons...)! :D

The writers are smart, they could come up with other ways for bringing Elsa into the story. Plus, it looks like she's going to be a villain, so it's not doing good for anyone really lol. Plus, Regina's happiness wouldn't have been ruined and Emma wouldn't be in Regina's bad books. Even though I don't believe she's dead but still...

For me, this isn't about Regina's happiness. It's about Emma fiddling with the timeline, despite Hook's warnings. Yes, Rumpel is partially guilty for opening up the time portal with Zelena's death. But Emma is also guilty.

She really needs to get over her "savior" role. Emma had fulfilled that role when she broke the original curse at the end of Season 1. She needs to get over this belief that she always have to be "the savior" and resume being Emma Swan. If Emma wanted to save Marian so badly, she could have allowed the woman to find her family in the Enchanted Forest of the past. Instead, Emma assumed that Marian would never find her family, went against the latter's wishes and dragged her into the 21st century and Storybrooke. We've already seen the mess she created with Regina's love life. It's interesting that no one is considering the upheaval that her actions will have on Robin Hood and his future relationship with Marian . . . and God knows what else.

For me, this isn't about Regina's happiness. It's about Emma fiddling with the timeline, despite Hook's warnings.

That's exactly why I'm not on her side. As I said in my first comment; one of the huge rules of time travel is not to tamper with things.

Can I be in the neutral third party corner because I think I'd be on both of their sides. Can't we just get the two of them together, reveal the truth about what Rumple did, and have them blame him for it?

I would like that to be honest. He needs to be found out and soon. But as usual they'll just let him away with it, the characters and writers.