i think he would be good... i mean he is very handsome... and there is somthing magical about him!

I know! if you go to imbd.com and type in his name to look at his pics, the picture for the "maybe" makes his eyes look edward cullenish [lol love that word] i mean they look like they could change colors! all they would need to do is make his hair a bit more bronzish and his skin paler.

He looks good but also for me it depends on his voice and how good he is at acting and BEING Edward :)

He's the closest looking to how i imagined Edward but i agree with you 100% sweetmonkeytoes. I've never seen him act so i can't really say how good he would be AS Edward.
He certainly is gorgeous though!!

He looks good, but does he act, walk, and sound good?

Hes hot like Edward.

Not exactly with the three "!!!"s but, i do think he makes a good Edward.

It all depends on how well he can BE Edward. like you all said before.

I'm ok with Robert being Edward now. But he would have been fine too! Right on imprint!

Im ok with Rob as Edward, but yeah i would of been fine with Colten being Edward but i dont really know anything about him - could he even BE Edward?

Gaspard is a lot better though, but hes still okay i guess

Honestly, I've never heard of that person.

He's good looking. More so than Robert P. I like him!

Seriously, the movie is going to ruin the magic for me. Rob is just not "drop dead gorgeous" enough

Who?

Who is that?

Rob Pattinson all the way xxx

He looks good but I've never seen him in anything, and Robert Pattinson will be great.

I really like Pattinson. Give him a break he is a very good looking and good actor.

He could but they have chosen Robert pattinson now people should stop this theyve chosen and i think they have chosen well he is perfect for edward in my opinion = )

once again. sawabear is my hero.

he looks better than robbert
and if u look at his pics on yahoo,,, he looks way more like a vamp....
i still like rob... he is a cutie too

No Robert is going to make a prefect Edward Cullen.

who is he?.. what has he been in?

he's cute but idk who he is

robert pattison is the perfect edward !!!!

idk who he is but he is a totall cutie

Idk who he is and I think Rob was the perfect Edward.
And Rob looks hotter too, but that pics crap so its hard to tell.

he kinda looks like a vamp!! lol but not as gawwd as rob!!!

dont knoe who he is...seen his pic..buh still want rob...<3

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

lovee ur answer twilightfan.............x

Yes i think so,he was one my top 3,so yes,never piture Robert Pattinson as Edward Cullen,and he not good either so,its pretty sad,because he is so good in his others roles:)