To me the Athena in Percy J seems more wise then Thoth, Thoth tome is just incredibly smart.

y would i pick a bird-headed god than a normal goddess? besides, thoth scares me of his form...

I thought Thoth was kinda' funny.

In the books, Thoth is more fun to hang out with, and Athena is just too serious. so Thoth it is ^^

Thoth was way more fun to read about. athena is cool, but kinda boring...

the book had thoth as kind of ditzy...but i like him more in actual mythology and in the books Thoth was more important and fun.

Athena seemed more appropriate for wisdom, thoth just sort of struck me as a mad scientist or something

I like them both but Thoth is really funny and Athena is kinda 'evil' towards Percy X(

Thoth's awesome. Athena may be wise but she's a stick in the mud. Intelligence doesnt mean you have to be boring

uhhh... thoth is the kind of guy u have a slice of pizza with, athena is the kind of woman u go to art meseum with... i like them both but i really got to say athena... it depends what mood im in if im looking fo a good time i hang w/ thoth if i wanna here about the the new books being released i got to athena...

I like Thoth, but Athena just seems more wise to me.

Thoth is okay, but Athena is a little more amusing. She has a way of saying things to Percy (if you know what I'm talking about), and she disapproves, but she doesn't do anything to Percy, which means she changed her mind, in, like, a split second?

girlz rule
not that i have anything against bird people

Reyna, I get what you mean. Athena says stuff- but she never really told you.

Athena because She seems more.......all around smart like book smart and battle plan smart like street smart where Thoth is more book smart and that's it.I'm saying this because I more pro-Greek gods instead of Egyptian BUT I like the Egyptian gods as well.If you ever read the Iliad by Homer (It's an Epic Poem about the Trojan War) and Athena makes me laugh and she plays a key part in that book also.

Athena is my mommy. :]

OMG THOTH DOES NOT COMPARE TO ATENA'S AWESOMENESS!!!!!

thoth was nicer to the main characters i.e. carter

Athena wins this game!

Athena is 100% better than Thoth. She defiantly has my vote!

Only because he seems more civil, and understands the mortal world better.

Thoth was really funny to me.

THOT ES MUCHO MAS PODEROSO

I love Athena! But come on, Thoth, if im incorrect, correct me, created the House of Life... He make an important role in the books....... She doesnt play a huge role in the PJ series... The Mark of Athena its just a conflict that made Annabeth and Percy fell in fucking Tartarus.

Thoth made horus a new eye And put Isis's head back on her body
Did Athena do that
I didn't think so