im sorry but how is peyton winning? she is not the bravest i mean why should she be she has been through so much i think she is a lot more braver now but i wouldnt use brave to describe her
i picked nathan coz he jumped in that lake he took the shot and won the championship when he new what stuff could of happened but i do think that thye are all brave

nathans the brave cause of what ^^ said! plus he went into the school shooting to save haley!
peytons brave cause - i mean she did convince pyscho derek that she was on his side wanting to kill brooke! if that was me i would of been a state! she has been through quite a bit and its made her stronger!
brooke is brave too cause she could of walked out of the house and left peyton in there but she never she went back and fought! however peyton and brooke couldnt sleep on there own for like a week afterwards!
haley - she got hit by a car to save nate!
lukes brave! he went into the school and saved peyton! cause at that time he didnt know it was jimmy - it could of been terrorists for all he knew, but he still went in! plus luke jumped into the lake after nate,coop and rachel were under! he saved peyton from pyscho derek the first time and also looked out for her when he was around!
derek:'so peyton,whod you bring?'
peyton:'wa you mean'
derek:'you dont strike me as a dumb girl, so whod you bring as backup incase i turned out to be a psycho'
[luke turns around]
peyton:'derek, lucas. lucas,derek'!
lol! he has suspicions about derek since the beginning and was very protective, and you cant forget hes always saving her
'your always saving me' 'somebodys got to'!

all in all i think lukes probably the most brave!

agree with you Laurra. I can't belive lucas is losing this!

I can't believe that Peyton is winning this! I mean, i love Peyton, but c'mon! She is not the most brave, at least when compared with Nathan and Lucas. What did Peyton after all? She faced a lot of bad things, like Derek and loosing two moms, but i don't call that brave. I call that strong!

Lucas without doupt!He has saved everyone in this show at least one time! Dan,Peyton,Coop&Racher with Nate and well I think that's enough! He never had fear to fight for the people he loves!!

Laurra you said some great and true things!!

i totally agree with Laurra..Luke practically has saved all of them!!Peyton is brave coz after all the staff that happened to her she grew stronger but she is not the bravest!!Luke is without a doubt!!

Nathan for reasons already listed.
Lucas definitely 2nd
And like many before me I'm wondering how Peyton is winning?!!?

All of them are definately brave.
But haley willingly got hit by a car just to save nathan from getting hit by a car.
Brave enough for you?

^^ how did i know you was gonna pick her! you have a right to your opinion but i think your blinded by who you like! that it all haley has ever done! nate and luke risk there lives for people all the time and you think haleys braver? sorry but i have to disagree with you!

haley jumping in front of a car when preggers is more stupid than brave!

Damn! I hate him but it's true he's very brave he saved Dan from the fire too.....Damn!!!