Loved all of the emotions of Haley giving Peyton the Baby Book, and Brooke being so happy that Sam showed up. Plus I feel that the baby shower was more centered around Peyton and the baby instead of other people's storylines.

Haley's was great as well, I loved when Brooke told her that she was adopting, but I feel that the baby shower aspect was overshadowed by whether Chloe was going to change her mind after hearing everybodys' stories. Plus when Millie decided to be stupid and start talking about her coke addiction in front of somebody that she didn't know pretty much ruined the whole thing for me.

Much more emotional and meaningful.

Agree, it was way more sweet and it showed how much people were worried about her. The whole thing was just so emotional.

Haley had a baby shower? Really? Could have fooled me. I thought that was just a lame get-together, with one secondary character hogging screentime after another. It hardly focused on Haley, or the baby at all. It was cheesy, unmeaningful, and pretty much pointless. Peyton's was actually heartfelt, and had a purpose.... A foreign concept to the show, these days :/

^ lmao. no contest! peytons was an actual legit baby shower. haleys wasn't at all!

Haha kinda agree Kelly. But it was cute:)
But Peyton's was way better.

I'll go and watch the scene now to judge fairly, but something tells me I'm not gonna pick it, so.... :P

Oook, I closed the video when they got to *chug chug chug chug chug*.....unbelievably ridiculous.

^ Hahaha. Yeah, chanting CHUG has NO place at a baby shower! Stupid, stupid writers...

By miles.

<3 i miss peyton :S

At least it was focused on the person actually HAVING the baby.