Peyton, blah.

Both are pretty

Honestly neither. Peyton I guess is slightly better.

"Peyton"'s a little bit more unique...that's all.

Peyton is more unique!

LOVE the name Peyton :D

Peyton's rly unique love it <3

Peyton sounds so good, I really like the name

As much as I like the name Peyton, there are so many male Peytons/Paytons at my school, that it just seems like more of a masculine name.

I'm probably the only one who actually doesn't like the name Peyton.
Like Seddie4ever said, it's too masculine.

Hilarie is one of my favorite names though!
But I prefer it written Hilary.

I like the name Hilarie. Don't like Peyton that much.

I love the name Peyton

It sucks that the Hilarie pick has got a way better picture, though :D

i like the name Hilarie, i love the name Peyton though -its is an amazing name.
Dalma, i was thinking completley the same thing, the hilarie pic looks gorgeous doesnt it?

Peyton it's really a great name! So unique! <3

Hilarie it's OK, but it's kind of common :/

fifty fifty lol

Peyton .

Peyton is less used and i hate how she spellls Hilarie. but i like them both

always and forever <3

Better:)