hello! how many times did lucas string brooke and peyton along? sure, nathan screws up on occasion, but at least haley's happy

Why can't you people choose not based on how much you like the character or how hot they are? Lucas played both Brooke and Peyton people, I guess you guys rather get played just to have a hot boyfriend. I picked Skills because he was the only one that remained faithful to Bevin throughout their whole relationship. Chase was faithful too but he wasn't on the show for that long.

Yup i sooo agree! With Lucas it would be like, you gotta be all OH BE WITH ME all he time or he might go running to someone else, nathan is PLAIN OUT annoying now & skills && chasr rock =) for hotness i would pick dan...LOL!

NATHAN FOR SURE, atleast he changed his ways..lucas is a player..he played brooke and cheated BOTH TIMES he was in a relationship with brooke!!

HES KIND , GOOD LOOKING , SENSATIVE , HE IS THE PERFECT BOYFRIEND

I love Mouth! He's so sweet. I think he would try his best and impress a girl to make her love him. I love him. I would totally want him to be my boyfriend. Plus he has the dork-y side with him. Which is a total plus.

he changed bcoz he loved Haley.
how can it b Lucus he cheated twise.

lmfao whoever picked dan is my hero.

I wouldn't pick lucas because he changes who he loves so much. Peyton then Brooke then Peyton then Brooke!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lucas would cheat on you... with Peyton

Lucas-is-a-sweat-guy

lucas is like such a perfect guy:) but he does tend to mess the girls aroundd..

are you kidding me lucas would be the worst boyfriend look at him on the show if you chose him you stupid he is such an ass going back and forth between Peyton and Brooke

He's adorable! And he was so sweet to Brooke.

tied between lucas and nathan...

Nathan has always been faithful to Haley, even with the whole Carrie incident. Lucas is a horrible boyfriend, he always cheats and never keeps his word, seriously and he as a bad case of denial.

NATHAN!!! ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥

Also Mouth and Skills :D

nathan, he's a good husband. so probably him.

Because we could spend the whole night talking about Basketball

mouth would be the best one i think lol

i love that man!!
i wanted too pick nate too, but i don't think i could stand all the drama around him... :/

JAKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Nathan and Jake!
Lucas is a cheater... ;|

nathan is amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NATHAN<3
'cause he would do everythin 4 u !

and maybe Jake he's cute , 2.

ssssssssssssssooooooooooooooooooooo sexy

NATHAN ROYAL SCOTT all the way !!!! sexy,sweet,sexy,kind,sexy,romantic,sexy,fu­nny­,go­od dad, did i mention sexy :)

love lucas too but nathan is so much of a better boyfriend(:

Lucas has always been a wonderful boyfriend to Peyton

even when i love lucas... i dont want a boyfriend that kisses my best friend!

NATHAN IS sweet,romantic, & everything I would want in a guy♥

not only is he beautiful, he's sweet, he would give anything for you, he's romantic, he's truthful, he admits his mistakes, and he would do anything to be with you. i love him. oh and carambolas DO YOU EVEN WATCH OTH haha

always and forever <3