I was totally freaked out and I felt SO SORRY for Peyton!

Because he was known as a monster when he died... poor kid.
I actually felt the worst when he died. Then keith and Q.
I wasn't really affected by Ellie's death... but it breaks my heart on how much peyton was :(

I think they all were really sad. Yea i felt bad for Peyton, she was just getting to know her mom and that happens to her.

Agree with 1treehillfan. Poor Jimmy. I almost cried with his great performance.

That was soo sad. I loved Ellie and seeing Peyton like that was heartbreaking. Second would be Jimmy. That moment was so powerful. Qs was sad too but it didn't get to me as much and Keith, well I never liked him so I wasn't that sad

His actual death was not that sad but some of the later episodes like when Luke and Karen see him in their dreams or whatever you want to call them were absolutely heartbreaking!! Q's death is a very close second though

His line "it hurts everyday it's hurts in here!" (not exactly right but near enough) was so devestating - don't get me wrong though it may have been the saddest to watch but i felt most sorry for Q as he didn't take his own life he had it taken from him D=

i pick this,but sad was wery when ellie died.poor peyton

Oh PLEASE! Keith was waaay more important then Q!! And they didn't overdue the Keith thing like they did with Q

they were all awful but this episode was the worst but good at the same time.

god this was so sad :(

this is too hard to pick! i mean none of these people deserved to die at all. Keith's was just so shocking and so sad for lucas and especially karen because she was pregnant and engaged to him, Ellie's was probaby the least sad but it was still so heartbreaking seeing peyton find her second mom dead, Jimmy's was also so sad because he was just a normal guy who felt like everyone left him behind and forgotton about him plus the fact that he thought the only way out of that mess was to kill himself really makes you feel for the guy, and finally Q's death was so sad because he was so young and he had so much going for him.

but i think Q's funeral was the saddest :(

Q or Keith!!

but Q more because he was such an ass at the beginning and then he turned around and was a guy we all became to love!! im sad he's gone ):

B/C Jimmy felt so hopeless, I mean he died with a heart full of pain.
Ellie, Keith, and Q all died after at least experiencing happiness. Ellie with Peyton, Keith with Karen, and Q w/ basketball; plus none of the them wanted to die.
I think it's so sad that Jimmy was so miserable that he saw no light at the end of the tunnel that he died in pure misery. It's just awful.

All these were really sad death's because somebody was affected by them. I picked Q's death because little kids were involved.

That whole episode i BAWLED.

When Q died, I teared. But 3X16...oh man, cant beat that.

i think i feel that Q's was the saddest because of the way they showed people mourning him, i think 603 was well written emotionally and that sams paper summed it up pretty well.
i was a keith fan and i hated that he died but with keith it was shadowed alot by the fact dan killed him and the reactions were mainly from lucas and karen, which were heartbreaking at points.

Q's mother is primarily the reason why I cried, she was so strong yet so broken. And then there was the Jamie factor, which I actually think he did a great job, along with Q's brother for such young ages. because Q was so young I think that the level of grief and the amount or number of people actually affected by it was expressed greater than the other deaths. Although Jimmy was very sad bc you could just tell how scared he was. He went down for Keiths murder too.

That was so sad =(

It was so sad. WIth the CD's being printed, and the song playing in the background! I totally cried. And then Peyton walking in to see her mother's dead!
Jimmy's comes second.

Jimmy edwards is a VERY close seccond

They were all awful! But I mean, the look in Keith's eyes when Dan point the gun at him, oh my god! Jimmy Edwards is 2. That episode I cried my heart out! But then again, i did when Ellie and Q died too..
But Q's funeral was very very sad though :(

keith dying was sad cuz he was everyone friend and he was finally gunna marry karen and luke had a father figure. everyones was really sad..

q's death was the sadest because it showed ALL the characters in a down place!! keith's comes in next. i loved keith!! i cried every time i watched that episode!! then jimmy. jimmy was really upset and mouth broke my heart!!then ellie!! i really liked ellie!!

I didn't cry when the others died, But when Q got killed, I cried. He was turning his life around, And being a big brother/ Friend to Jaime.

Keith's death was the saddest! I still can't forgive Dan!

I Agree With Nine00^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

I loved Q ={

theres something really tragic in the death of a youth. someone soo young with soo much too look forward to just dying soo randomly and unexpectedley. deffo the saddest, the entire funeral had me bawling like a baby, the first time the show made me cry.

Keith Ellie and then Q