pinkie pi is more scaryier then fluttershy she seems more kinder then pinkie

Well, I originally designated Pinkie as Scary among the Spice Ponies, but at the Gala...egads...Fluttershy forced me to reconsider that decision!! After all, Pinkie COULD also be Baby...xD

But these both are danged frightening!
Pinkie & Fluttershy are two characters who can be made quite terrifying...Pinkie certainly more so, but I'm still gonna go with wacked-out Fluttershy in this case. Slightly. Oh-so very, very slightly...

Fluttershy went wacko at the Gala... :( And pinkie's just naturally crazy... But in general they're both my two top faves.

Pinkie went schizo in that one episode.

she gave me the chills

Pinkie Pie's crazy on a daily basis, anyways. xD

man,i was scared by pinkie with straight hair and she would be talking for objects... creepy O_O

Pinkie Pie.
She has photographic memory, precognition, manic-depressive bipolar disorder, can be in two places at once, defies the laws of gravity, and is faster than Rainbow Dash.

Pinkie Pie is scary.

Fluttershy's crazy side is more of a surprise, because you don't expect it from her, but she didn't creep me out like Pinkie Pie did. Fluttershy was just kinda funny. XD

Pinkie Pie's insanity isn't so much a shocker, but she freaked me out in "Party of One"!

"You're going to LOVE ME!!!!!!!!!"

WACKY!!!

hell she's creepy

Definitely Pinkie! Fluttershy is just flat out raging during this scene, but Pinkie has a very insane and unpredictable side to her during the episode.

but I love Pinkie Pie xD

I <3 Pinkie Pie, but this reminded me too much of Cupcakes. 8| Should not have mentioned that. DO NOT READ CUPCAKES.

YOU'RE... GOING TO LOVE ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!­!

O_O.......

Fluttershy is intense when she breaks out of her shy personality. When Pinkie Pie goes crazy, I just felt sorry for her. Oh, and I refuse to go along with anything related to the fanfic Cupcakes (horrid creation). That's not MY Pinkie Pie!!

i gotta say pinkie pie,pinkie pie has more craziness and insanity inside of her. watching "party of one" i was like "pinkie pie must be a bit knocked off" than when she turned insane "WHAT THE HELL!!that is just too creepy her mind is taking control of her body! i really freaked out when her eyes turned derped! and she is full of surprises!like her mind can control her,she looks like she is half good and bad,too crazy,and surprisingly faster than rainbow dash!
i'm totally freaked out by her at the other episodes.... 0_o

Fluttershy she has shown more time, going into bursts of rage.

That was a hard desition thery're both creepy but Pinkie kinda gives me the chills ..

Crazy Pinkamena in this one

Fluttershy was just creepy. For a second when I looked at the picture I almost screamed

Crazy Pinkie is just creepy O.O

link

nuff said

I know Fluttershy would apologize later, but Pinkie really scares me. They way her eyes go back like that........ *shivers*

It was hard but I did it i like Fluttershy better though my list of favs is Aj Flutttershy rarity Rainbow pinkie then Twilight

Fluttershy freaked me out. And let's face it, normal Pinkie isn't much different from crazy Pinkie.

I'm super super scared of her

I wouldn't want to meet her in a dark alley...

I'm afraid of both, but I was scared of this picture before I was a brony...

OK its getting weird

I knew pinkie had an insanity in her personality.

Crazy Fluttershy is much more scarier than pinkiepie

CRAZY TWILIGHT IS SCARIER THAN BOTH OF THEM.

But if I had to pick, I would say tie. Crazy Pinkie is freaky and delusional, but Crazy Flutter is suicidal.

I PICK CRAZY TWILIGHT.

I had 2 pick myself, cuz when I go crazy, I actually scare MYSELF! yeah sorry everypony, u know, about when I went crazy at the gala? yeah, sorry about that

CUPCAKES. That says it all. Haven't read it yet? Don't. Unless you want to think of Pinkie Pie as a psycho lunatic that kills ponies for entertainment.

Just re-watched Party of One and I decided to change my answer. Crazy Pinkie is just creepy!

That part freaked me out

cupcakes *shiver*

You have to watch out for the ones who are quieter when angry.

You should see her in amnesia. My friend made a my little pony amnesia fan club so you can see her.

That really freaked me out.

When Pinkie goes crazy, her hair is like when she was a young filly before she knew how to smile.

It was beyond her normal crazy...but it was pretty funny X)

pinkie is noraly crazy but when fluttershy does it it's like wow O_O

When Pinkie is crazy she is my CLONE(personality wise, im not pink ya know!)

She really freaked me out

This one, she reminds me of mah friend Valerine....CRAZY!!! I mean, Valerine is like Fluttershy's inner monster! She's so kind and sweet and adorable! shes like the best friend a person could have until....One day we had a sleepover at mah house, we have these neibors that has two children, a 6 year old girl, and a 5 year old boy. Their parents asked us if we could babysit, and we accept. For some reason the children hated Valerine. Well that was a bad thing to say....Because valerine loves playing with little kids. She tried everything to make these kids to love her, but nothing worked.....Then she said "Guess we have to do it the hard way!" She forced the children to go to the park, I asked her if she wanted me to come, but she said no. So ah stayed in the house reading a book. After 20 minutes, the children started running torwards me crying(Valerine wasnt there yet). Then we heard a loud noise. Suddenly Valerine opened the door harshly, she was with messy hair, and scars. Then she screamed "Come...out...and..PLAAAY!!!!" her eye was twitching. *shivers*

"You´re gonna love me!" ._. She really scared me in Best Night Ever. How she did her crazy laugh and when she says "COME OUT" on the Pony Pokey song

That's not the Pinkie we know and love :(

.

she look's scarier

I herd pinkie pie turns ponys into cupcackes, but I have to go with the actual show O_O

i think pinkie is way more scary, since she went a bit insane. After all fluttershy was mostly just enraged and it was kinda a relief (and also very funny) to see her that way for once.

1 word: CUPCAKES!

when flutter shy goes crazy-i avoid seeing that face again! i can imagine her going crazy on me!

This episode scared me.

She almost gave ma a heart attack!

How bout crazy Twilight?

DEFINETLY KREEPY , i mean have u seen the comic "CUPCAKES".......HUHUHUH.......S­O MUCH BLOOD!

One word: Cupcakes. Just kidding; even though Cupcakes is gory and scary, the party scene took on an insane Twist when the half a second long scenes of the paint splattered walls appeared, and they still scare me a bit.

remeber cupcakes

My vote would go to Pinkie. Because the way she had the psychotic ticks from time to time during the "Party Of One" episode. And then she finally snaps. And thus, "Cupcakes" was born. *shivers* Never again...

cupcakes started it

I refer to her as her Cupcakes identy
Pinkamena

O_O ...physcopath..they both turned insane...

It's no contest

Pinkie is always a bit crazy and that little bit more didn't really concern me. But Fluttershy...

flutterrage was just angry but pinkie was acting like a psycho murdered. Have any of you read cupcakes?!

Pinkie was so frudjing scary on Party on One (frudjing=freaking).

O_o

Cupcakes bro. Cupcakes.

Pinkie looked like a psycho. She was totally out of her mind and din't know what she was doing which made her too unpredictable. She completely lost her sanity where as fluttershy was just a little scary and very angry.

SHE GONNA CUT YOU

CUPCAKES!!!

I had to choose Pinkie Pie. When Flutter Shy went crazy, I found it more funny then scary. Pinkie Pie, however. Now that is a different story. Think about it, she is speaking to inanimate object that she thinks are making negative comments about her friends. Not good enough for you? Well, if you are brave enough, I suggest reading Cupcakes. Watch it and you will see why I think Pinkie is scarier... And you'll also see why I prefer muffins.

When a kind pony such as herself (the Element of Kindness, no less!) has gone crazy, things can and will get real ugly real fast!

NOOOOOOOOOOOOO I DON'T WANT YOUR CUPCAKES NOWWWW

Its Pinkimena VS Murdershy...

*Laughs* Funny how Pinkie finally dropped her fake smile. Her insanity took over her, along with a teaspoon of darkness. Cupcakes? Realize she kills to make herself happy.. She kills for no one to hurt her..

O.O .................

She looks like she out for more blood than Crazy Pinkie.

those eyes man o.o Those eyes........

Crazy Fluttershy is my dominatrix.

Crazy Pinkie Pie because she looks like that creepy picture of Princess Celestia and I think she's used in more creepypastas than Flutterbitch

Pinkie is already crazy but she is angry, she really really really really really crazy!!!

Pinkie isn't scary.

I thought she was having schizophrenia or something... O.o

Pikemana is actually a nice name.

Well not really 'scarier', just a bit... off. *shivers*

run before she kills us all and makes us into cupcakes

some people would think that just because Fluttershy is quieter and shyer than Pinkie makes her the scariest. But that is not always true. it is obviously Pinkie Pie

She reminds me of that gross video Cupcakes where she kills RD. So horror.

Pinkie's craziness was more depressing and subtle.

reminds me of clod from Dumb ways to die and its scary O,O whoever plays that game and likes it than high five X3 Regular pinkie is definitely Hapless, her smily attitude, her talkative way that she speaks X3 and she might get her phone out in the movies like he did to lol and gummy is the grizzly bear bc why not? OH! am i to crazy for u guys? sorry I'm gonna stop....

For those who have seen Smile HD you will know why I picked her...