|
Skyraven said:
Harry Potter was más successful than Twilight in many ways. First off, it had much más excitement and action in it, and many of the good guys die along with the bad. In Twilight, it has a big happy 'all-of-us-survived-and-the-bad-people-are-dead' ending. People like action and thrills, they don't want to sit there and read about Edward's looks for fifty pages o about how miserable Bella is without him. And speaking of Edward and Bella, the characters in Harry Potter were all realistic. They had their flaws, their strengths, none of them were absolutely perfect and loved por everyone. Take Hermione for example. She can be annoying, o a know-it-all, but without her, Harry and Ron would be doomed. On the contrary, Bella is perfect, beautiful, and loved por everyone. The minuto she steps into her school, all of the guys want to fecha her. She's absolutely depressing, flawless, and cannot live without Edward por her side. Unlike Hermione, who's brave, independent, and willing to fight, Bella needs her guy for everything and is pretty much useless as a human. She also thinks that Edward stalking her and watching her sleep is romantic, which is a terrible example for young girls. It might trick them into believing that they cannot live without a man, that stalking is okay. It is NEVER okay! The Harry Potter plot, even though it involves wizards and magic, is very original in the events, while Twilight is just another vampire amor story. In HP, there's always danger, trials, and inner troubles the characters have to face. In Twilight, there's about five pages of action and then everything's solved. That's it. These are HUGE reasons contributing to why Harry Potter is so much más successful-it has a deep, thought-out storyline that every Harry Potter fan can lose themselves in, realistic characters that we amor and relate to, plenty of excitement and action that leaves us wondering what happens next. When our favorito! characters die, we seem to never stop grieving for the loss even if it is fiction. Even when the Deathly Hallows ended and we set the book down, it seems to never really end. That's why Harry Potter is más successful-it has everything a real literature lover wants. Action, adventure, a good plot, developed characters, deaths on both sides, and real romance. People do not fall in amor por looking at each other. All of the romance in Harry Potter was spread over the years; the two started as friends, and it grew into something stronger, deeper. While Twilight may have 'hot' guys, romance and drama, all that, it only really appeals to teenage girls, while anyone can read and enjoy Harry Potter. Nobody likes an unoriginal plot, o weak characters, no action....that's why Harry Potter was always a step ahead of Twilight in success.
|
|