both were good

Easily,my 2nd favorite episode

I didn't care for Extraordinary much it seemed like it would have been heaps better if they didn't chop it up so much. Maybe beause the bulk of it was inspired by some of the trippiest, boosing christmas specials. But over all it didn't fit with the episode before and was over the top Corney.

A Very Glee Christmas seemed to fit better with the episodes before and was still very glee like.

I don't know which to choose. The one in Season 2 had better storylines, but the one in Season 3 had better songs. They're both so amazing.

Ya I liked both of them but the 1 in the 3rd season was better because it had better songs and sue didn't bash them this year. And im the last 1 Kurt was at a different school and sue bashed them. So I like the Extraordinary Merry Christmas better

Kurt + Blaine + Let it Snow = perfection <3