I also love Finn's performance =]

I love both of the songs but performance wise Puck was more of a showman while Finn wasn't singing for people so he had no reason to put on a show.

ARE. YOU. KIDDING ME??? Pucks, of course! Puckpuckpuckpuckpuck!!! Always. XD
I like Finn's voice, deffo, just not as much. And sometimes he can be very weak. I do like him in Stand By You, but it's just the song... not... great....

love Finns voice much more :) Puck had just better song to sing :P

How is this even a close competition haha?

Mark has the better voice. He should be singing duets with Lea.

I really don't care much for Finns voice. And Puck rocked Sweet Caroline <3

I LOVE Sweet Caroline too, but this is one of my favorite songs ever. So I have to go with Finn on this one.

@swimchick - I'm asking myself the same question.

Puck needs more solos! I would also love to hear Mark doing more solos. Finn's voice is pretty good when they don't freaking auto-tune it. Most of the time he sounds like a robot. I think he sounded the best when he was singing in the shower. Oh-natural. ;D

i like Puk's "Sweet Caroline" but Finn's "I'll Stand By You" is soooooooooo incredibly sweet!! <:3

No freaking doubt.

Finn is the best male singer in the new directions