i cant choose because both seem like they would be good fathers and yes i know that finn is seem as the "dumb" one but that doesnt mean he would be a bad father, he would learn like all knew parents do and puck well he seems very committed and even though his a man whore he would still care for the child JUST likee Finn so im stuck on this question DAMN ME FOR MAKING A PICK LIKE THIS AGAIN...

But i will wait for everyone else and what they have to say than choose lol

I think that both can handle being a father well.
I went with Puck just because he's already proven how much he cares about the baby regardless of him being a womanizer and having needs and all those stupid stuff he said in 1x11.

What Nat said^^

I think Finn really shined in "I'll stand by you"

He cared so much about Drizzle! I think Finn would be such a cute daddy.
Well, they both would be actually.

Both would be great :)

Lol, Drizzle! :P

I genuinely think they would both be amazing. Will would be a great father too. Poor Will. :(

I think that if it hadn't been revealed that Puck was really Baby Drizzle's father (LOL Shandiii!), Finn might've harbored just a liiiittle resentment towards the kid (and Q). Quinn didn't really give him a choice, after all ("Pay these bills. Buy me preggo clothes. You're the father of my child, dammit!"). Puck, even when nobody knew and Quinn didn't want him to be a part of it, still tried to help Quinn/spawn however he could. They both have the potential to be a good father, I just think Puck would be more... enthusiastic? Sincere? There's a proper word for this, somewhere. =P

Puck. Because at least he's smart enough to know you can't get pregnant by D-effing in a hot tub. Honestly.

Both would be great but Puck would really commit :D

I believe Puck can do anything :P

I think they both would be amazing fathers, but Finn was trying soooo hard to be there for "Drizzle" he wanted to raise her well.


Puck also would be a great father! If he stopped putting his "needs" above everything else.... I think he really does care for "Drizzle" (I actually kinda like that name), but he needs to man up some more before he can be a daddy...


so I think both would Fantastic fathers I just think Finn might be able to not cheat on Quinn a little better!!!!

i think they would both be fantastic fathers but Puck shows that he really does care and he's tried really hard to measure up i think Finn would be great too but i mean Puck seems to try so hard

It depends.

In general, i think Finn maybe.
But to Quinn's baby, i think Puck. Because he truly cares about them. <3

finn is such a bad father because he is so immature and is always going behind quinns back with rachel and acts like hes innocent.
even when quinn does go behind finns back she doesnt act like the victim.
puck can provide foe the child and i honestly beleive he would stay true to quinn if she gave him another chance

I think Finn is a little bit more naturally caring -- Puck kind of has to work at it. Plus, since he lost his own dad, he places a bigger emphasis on family and has a greater appreciation for fatherhood in general. Plus, he already loves the baby so much (see "Ballad"), whereas I think Puck just wants to win over Quinn.

Finn's too helpless.

I don't think either of them would be :S

both but it depends on whos baby it is

both would be amazing fathers

So hard but probley Finn