Critical Analysis of Twilight Club
registrarse
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
Preface:
I have read all libros and seen the movies.
Most importantly, the fact that it’s fantasía doesn’t excuse the themes and messages in the book. Fiction is merely a vehicle humans developed to communicate important lessons, values and philosophies. I am not claiming any of the implications I discuss were intentional on SMeyer’s part. Whether o not the autor o readers are aware of it, though, the Twilight series communicates dangerous messages about what is acceptable o admirable o desirable.
Also, I highly recommend link. It’s long, but fascinating and deeper than the libros themselves....
continue reading...
added by Plenilunio
Source: http://applesparkles.wikia.com
added by Mallory23
Source: www.fanpop.com/spots/twilight-crepusculo
I used to be a die-hard Twilight fan. (see my username. Damn I wish I'd chosen ANYTHING else sometimes.)

I still like the book in small doses now, and I even write fanfiction for it, but now I've looked critically at SMeyer's characters, and I think I realize what people are talking about when they say Bella cisne is a Mary Sue.

As a person who has seen it from both sides, I'd like to say that maybe Twilight fans didn't see Bella like that to begin with because she has so many "flaws".

I'm not really a mega-supporter of Bella's neediness. And I even, admittedly, wonder why she took Edward back after New Moon. Normal people with lives and better things to do would say, "Hell no am I taking tu back. tu left me crying in a forest, and tu think I'll just come running back to you? tu wanna commit suicide, go right ahead while I get the popcorn."

I still like Twilight. But maybe Bella cisne was kind of 2-Dimensional.
I dislike the books, but after seeing image after image labeled "Twilight sucks", as well as comentario after comentario with the words, I'm beginning to see why we can be accused of being "haters."

"Sucks" is not a swear word. To say something sucks is not going to send tu to hell. But it is derogatory, and immature, and does not lead to any real discussion. Well, unless some mature Twilighter comes along and say, "I see that tu think Twlight sucks. Why?" That might spark discussion. But the twilighter has the upperground in that debate, considering the anti has already shown her immaturity by...
continue reading...
added by nuxi
Source: Reasoning With vampiros Tumblr
added by mispulka
Source: deviantart.com
OK, this is my very first articulo - I have never written an articulo for fanpop before. It's a poor excuse if this turns out to be the poorest articulo ever submitted, but I'm going to use it anyway... please go easy on me xD. This is LONG, so oso, oso de with me, I appreciate it!

I have been wondering for some time now about Bella's vulnerability, state of mind, and en general, general mental well-being. New Moon, in the beginning, was my favourite book of the series, for two reasons: Jacob Black was instantly likeable and interesting, winning the título of my favourite character, but also the black hole that Bella...
continue reading...
aagh! I accidentally deleted this when I was trying to editar it. here it is again with a new title:

Bella could have gotten over Edward in New Moon and even had a real relationship with Jacob in time, but she wouldn't let herself. She felt that moving on would diminish o discredit her twu wuv with Edward and the pain she felt after he left. She wants to believe she can't get over it because she wants to believe that what they had was extraordinary, not like any other teenage romance. She wants to believe no one else in the world can relate to what she's going through. She was alone because she...
continue reading...
Ok people,no violence and bad response's allowed in here,
and I actually risked my life making a critical Edward Cullen spot already...so please understand:)

This is an extract taken from:
[u]Response to "Analysis of the Opposite!"
By:XDRoseLuvsHP
From:The HP vs. Twilight spot.
(link):

link

.................................................



A small extract:


Edward is, undoubtedly, an abusive boyfriend. Yes, I know that he has never hit her, he has never intentionally hurt her. Just so tu know, there are other types of abuse. Edward abuses Bella psychologically as well as abusing her rights. There may...
continue reading...
Ever since its reciente creation I have not been able to stop visiting this spot (Not that it's a problem...haha). I decided to sit down and ponder and from my pondering came this list.

1. Everybody rates EVERYTHING.
I mean EVERYTHING. Nothing goes unrated and everyone always rates fairly.

2. The foros are always buzzing.
I absolutely amor visiting the forums. Someone is always there looking to chat and the comentarios are sure to put a smile on my face.

3. I can have intelligent and enjoyable conversations
I don't feel like I talk to someone and all they have to say is, "OMG tu amor (insert...
continue reading...
LOL. Revamped. Get it? 'Cause like, Twilight has vampiros and stuff... [/lame]

Okay, the Momcat has FINALLY gotten off her fat, lazy butt and done some much-needed work on some of the rules for our spot. When the spot first got started, it was fairly small and having wiggle-room wasn't such a problem; so my first batch of rules weren't all that specific. But our CAT has had many, many new gatitos since then, and consequently, things have gotten crazier and messier. A lot of people have gotten confused about what this place is for, and what we're about. The CAT isn't what it used to be.

So hopefully,...
continue reading...
added by Dearheart
Source: marposa_nocturna (deviantART)
added by cassie-1-2-3
Source: twilightfacts@tumblr.com
added by cassie-1-2-3
Source: twilightfacts.tumblr.com
added by Riga93
added by ClaireVoyant
Source: not mine
As a fan of Twilight, I am part of a lot of related spots and discussions. However, as a Jacob & Bella fan, I often find myself disagreeing with most of the opinions of Twilight fans. In this articulo I'll go through some comentarios I've read (slightly altered - don't want anyone out to get me!) and why I disagree with them. It's really just an informal rant. :P

'Edward & Bella have things in common unlike Jacob & Bella'

... What exactly? Let me guess: Classical music? Bella knows one song and suddenly they have something in common. They both read? When do we actually read of Bella reading...
continue reading...
As someone who liked vampiros before the fad started I'm one of the many people who dislikes the Twilight vampires. And thinks they should be reclassified as pixies. o that at least Zombie Bram Stoker should go have a serious talk with Stephenie Meyer about vampires... What do tu mean Bram Stoker hasn't risen as a zombie in protest to the Twilight vampires? Why don't tu go prove it? I'll wait...

...

...They didn't come back, so I'm assuming Zombie Bram ate their brains. We'll have to carry on without them. Anyway, I must admit Meyerpires are an interpretation of the vampire myth I just don't...
continue reading...
i had nothing to do absolutely nothing to do. As i was so bored i began drawing through one of Dimitri's favorito! cowboy novels i had a feeling this would annoy him. suddenly i felt someone looming above me i turned around, it was Dimitri just as i thought he was going to be annoyed with me for sure.
"What are tu doing Roza?" he asked
I grinned. he picked up the novel that i was drawing in i hope he didn't see it.
"Ah one of favorito! books." he opened the book and saw my lovely work of art. He frowned at me.
"Busted." i laughed nervously
"Rose why are tu destroying my books?" he asked sternly...
continue reading...