I read the books first but I always got a doll for christmas. Good times!

I read the books first too. But I loved my dolls! Oooh, such a hard choice!

i love the dolls becuse you could act out the girls in the story while you read the books i never got one i always wanted all of them.

i mostly like the books...

I like both but the doll for me!

But that's because i was way over dolls by the time i got into the books. I don't even have any. They are so expensive.

i dont read books i hate books

i wish i had a american doll cause all my friends have one but there too expensive

Both, but I have a thing for doll's hair, lol ;)

I do read the books, but I like to make my own stories, so I like the dolls better.

you can cloccet dolls but books can get boring

duh

Children like to play with dolls, even if they aren't old enough to read.

I would just stick with the doll...

JUST WRITE A LETTER TO SANTA IF YOU DON'T HAVE AN AMERICAN GIRL DOLL OK???????????????????????????????!!!!!!!!

i love the books but i think the dolls are good too

The books have always been too easy for me!

if u choose ag books then y do u like ag dolls????

Because some people like the books more but still like the dolls?

oopps sorry

The books wouldn't be there without the dolls!