I thought of that. =( Although in all honesty, I'd rather him be the killer than have him die. He's too cute to die!

that would be UBER creepy in abby's case. EWWWWWWWW!!!!!

*spoiler for episode 10*
I am positive he's Wakefield son and even more now that we are certain Abby isn't. I just LOVE JIMMY. Props for the writers for creating such alluring story and such wonderful character. CJ Thomason gave him a charm impossible to resist. He and Abby make the greatest couple. He's the main reason I am watching. And it would be a wonderful writing success for the story to know he was the killer. And he MUST be John Wakefield's son. No wonder the Sheriff was always opposed to him being with Abby. It was not right for both half brothers to be together. But on the verge of death he gave up: "you could still have a life together with Jimmy".
Jimmy and Abby must be offsprings of the same mother, different parents.
Oh I was so happy when he was alive. Gosh I LOVE THIS SHOW!!!

I hope not. Just because of Abby. EW XP

I hope not i think that jimmy is being forced to help wakefield

i like harpers island but FUCK THE PEOPLE WHO MAKE IT THOSE FUCKERS KILLED JD AND CAL FUCK U FUCKING RETARD CREATORS FUCKING HOMO HORE BITCHES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I think it's Henry. Not for any logical reason, but just because he and Abby seem to look alike. And I ship Jimmy and Abby, and having them be half-siblings would just be awkward. :)

Yeah I know it would be awkward. But wouldn't it be just like... so tragically romantic!! So intense the sheriff gave up in opossing society and on the verge of death told his child to have a life with the one she loved (even if he knew they were half-siblings). Wow... tragic passionate lovers!!! argh! i just cant resist myself. I adore that couple. Not only they are cute... they are INTENSE!!!

It is Henry who is Wakefield's son

Although in Episode 12, I began to think Jimmy was Wakefield's son, I never thought so before. And the only reason I hoped he wasn't related to Wakefield was because then he would be Abby's half-brother and they dated and that would be sick! Ewwww!