I would pick Piplup because it's the only pokemon that can evolve into a water/steel type. It's also cute with pretty good attacks.

I would prefer mudkip. Because it will evolve to half ground type. And nobody will surpass it!

I would choose oshowatt

Well I'm nicknamed squirtle cuz I like squirtle. I like water type in general but todadile cuz he's plain out awesome but strategically I would choose mudkip cuz electric isn't super effective cuz it's part ground as well

Wow squirtle

Everybody thinks that mudkip is so Awaome because electric doesn't effect it but truthfully electric sucks anyway what people don't relize is that grass dose 8x the damage on mudkip seince grass super effects water and ground truthfully I do think mud kip is the best overall but if it was my first one ever I would choose piplup because it evolves into a water steel type which is Awaome