So.

OKAY so
Mami Tomoe is my icon.
My favourite character is Sherlock Holmes.

So really it depends on the type of fight.

If it were a physical fight, Mami would probably win because she's a magical girl and also has guns.
See, what happened was Mami went to Sherlock Holmes with a case and realised that *DUNDUNDUN* he was a witch! So she had to kill him and like take his grief seed because that's kind of, yknow, what Magical Girls do.
John Waston was his familiar.
TBH Sherlock Holmes would probably have a totally awesome witch's labyrinth like let's be real here.
Probably was like all dark and Victorian and had lots of dead things.
Y'all know how I am with dark and Victorian dead things.


NOW if it were a battle of wits, Sherlock Holmes would definitely win BECAUSE
Well
Um
'cause he's Sherlock Holmes?
I mean pretty self explanitory.
IDK what happens though because I don't know how a "Battle of Wits to the Death" would really even be a thing. Like what you're so smart at the other person that they are so ashamed of themselves that they do the suisided?
Dunno man.

Kazuma Yagami and Light Yagami
....
oh look they are both Yagami


oh well......obviously

well I have the same situation as you,Riku114.My icono is Robert Pattinson,and my fave character is Edward Cullen.Since Robert is human and his Twilight character is a vampire,it's seguro to say Edward would win.The fight would be over me...XD.But I would do something similar that Bella did in New Moon and stop the fight por saying tu can't hurt each other without hurting me.Since they don't want to hurt me,they agree to not fight each other.

Azula and Azula get into a fight. Don't know why, but I have a feeling Azula's gonna win this one.

Well my favorito! character is probably Miles Upshur from Outlast and my icono is Ruvik from The Evil Within so... I guess it really depends on where the fight takes place.

If it's in Ruvik's mindscape then Miles is literally screwed, because all it would take to kill him is a gentle bop to the forehead. If the fight happens in the real world, however, Miles would kick Ruvik's nerd ass.

My icono is Joey from SNF and plus he's my favorito! character. it would be a tie. Joey does have fighting skills but my icono and my favorito! character are the same person. XD

Okay so poor Hana is facing off against a god.
...She'd lose in a second. Unless it's that dark version of her from the song? Wait, she'd still lose.

Mine Sebastian and Sebastian demon so I couldn't beat him because he is immortal so the match would be like immortal vs mortal but if it was my anime character that is a different story it would be probably a tie

Even though there are 2 powerful characters in my icon, Sasuke would annihilate them within seconds.

Sasuke too op.

I have 3 favorito! characters, so I chose 1 of them. I'm pretty sure Starfire would win against ke$ha if they fought to death. I have no clue why they would fight yet.