Is Time a Problem for Game of Thrones? 

timeline makes absolutely no sense? We’re long

past the point of arguing that time within the world of the show actually works, but if you are a person who cares about this sort of thing — if a disregard for how fast fictional bodies could reasonably move around a fictional map was ever going to disrupt your ability to enjoy dragon battles

Sunday’s episode is the one that finally tipped you over the edge.

In “Beyond the Wall,” Jon realizes his merry band of wight hunters are in the midst of an ambush, so he orders Gendry to run back to the Wall and send a raven to Dany. Gendry sprints off, arriving back at Eastwatch sometime during the night. The raven is dispatched and flies nearly half the length of Westeros down to Dragonstone. Daenerys gets the raven’s message sometime during the day, and then hops on a dragon and flies up North to save Jon and his men.

You can do the math any way you want, but we have almost no idea how much time passes between these scenes. The distance from Eastwatch to Dragonstone is very fuzzy. The ravens aren’t necessarily real-world birds, so who knows how fast they can fly. We can’t even begin to guess how fast a dragon can travel. And who knows how long Jon and his men were huddled together on that ice island. Was it a few hours? A day? Do we even know for sure if there are 24 hours in a Westerosi day?

You could strain for explanations to justify how “Beyond the Wall” makes sense, concluding that a raven can fly 1,000 miles in a single night. You could also throw up your hands, concluding that it’s impossible and the story is now somehow broken. Or you could just say, “It’s a story! None of it’s real, but it sure was cool when the dragons showed up!”

: Which Side to Take in the Sansa Versus Arya Conflict

Here Are a Bunch of GIFs of Jon and Daenerys Staring at Each Other

has a long history of skipping the boring bits, and season seven leans into this tendency more than ever. We’ve seen episodes that find Jaime Lannister instantly leaping from King’s Landing to Highgarden, and Jon bopping around between Winterfell and Dragonstone like they’re next-door neighbors, as armies depart and arrive at their destinations with remarkable alacrity. These events are obviously impossible, but it’s also hard to blame the show for deploying them. George R.R. Martin himself has said that the characters’ stories don’t need to take place in lock step with one another, so why

cut straight to the fun parts where everyone meets up and the story actually happens?

fans caring a great deal about things like distances and travel speeds and whether the chronology makes sense. The end of season six sparked a wave of discussions on this point, to the tune of “wait, how much time has passed so far on this show?” and “why would you want to watch Arya on a boat for four episodes?” We can look up maps of where all the characters have been; we can ponder distances traveled. There is a bounty of speculation, information, and discussion waiting if you want to dive into it.

The time cuts in “Beyond the Wall” are noticeable enough that they definitively answer the question of whether

’s timeline makes any sense. It does not. So we come around again to the bigger question:

Why care about something as mundane and boring as distances and travel times in a world where there’s magic and giant wolves and red priestesses and whatever the hell Bran is? So what if

One reason people obsess about this sort of thing is that the realities of travel time and distances and grueling cross-country treks fit into the dubiously useful category of “relatability.” These characters’ lives are already unimaginably distant from our own, with their magical swords and fire-breathing dragons and majestic winter coats. If what you care about is putting yourself in their shoes, those shoes are harder to imagine when they can bend space and time itself.

There’s an even bigger issue with scrapping the commonplace logic that it takes a long time to get to faraway places: Without firm rules about time and geography, suddenly

becomes possible. The pressures that create obstacles for our beloved and reviled characters no longer feel all that hard to overcome. The strategic cost of sending Jon Snow beyond the Wall to collect a wight would be

if he were taking himself out of the diplomatic game for episodes on end, and his near-death moment in the ambush would be similarly colossal. Instead, we’re left with … you know, the battle is cool! The dragons are cool! But it doesn’t feel all that astonishing or impressive when Dany saves them, because apparently flying across the continent is just a thing someone can do without any further explanation.

This is the real problem with abandoning incontrovertible rules for space and time, even in a made-up universe like the one in

. Once your audience notices the fictional world is fickle, the seams of the whole thing become visible. Once you’ve seen behind the curtain of how the story works, you look at each event in the narrative for what it really is (a decision made to push the story forward) rather than what you’d like it to be (the story as a story, the end).

has been much stronger at building a wholly inhabited world in other ways, especially in terms of character. I have a sense of who Sansa is, who she was at the beginning of the series, and how her character has changed in concert with the events that’ve taken place in her life. I know Arya and I know the things that drive her. When

tells me that Sansa and Arya don’t trust one another, I believe that the situation is a real problem for them both. But it’s very hard to get excited about how imminent this White Walker threat is, since they’ve been marching ceaselessly for who knows how long and still haven’t gotten to the dang Wall. It’s too easy to see that delay for what it actually is: a writers room making the choice that it’s not yet time for the White Walkers to get where they’re going.

’s bonkers timeline doesn’t need to interrupt anyone’s enjoyment of the series. It’s certainly more fun to watch dragons swoop in and save the day (or fall out of the sky in a dramatic death that is somehow both icy

fiery) than it is to watch people trudge around a map forever. But if it does

bother you, there’s a good reason. You’re being pulled out of an otherwise immersive experience; you can see the wheels turning inside the narrative mechanism; you can recognize that someone adjusted the story to prioritize quickness over plodding realism.

are like a slightly too obvious trick in an otherwise impressive magic show. If you can see how that one trick works, does it ruin the rest of the performance? Can you still love the magic even after you see the artifice? A “yes” answer makes sense, but a “no” answer is reasonable, too. And if your answer boils down to “I don’t care, just gimme some dragons!” then I’m happy for you, too. After all, it was a pretty great battle.

Katy Perry’s ‘Swish Swish’ Video: Don’t Let Katy Near the

Allah-Las Rock Concert in Rotterdam Canceled After Terror Threat

Taylor Swift Declares the Old Taylor Dead on New Song, ‘Look What You Made Me Do’

Kim Kardashian Would Very Much Like to Be Excluded From the Narrative of Taylor Swift’s Return

Pulls The YA Book That Allegedly Gamed The Bestseller List Over ‘Inconsistencies’

Objectified Its Star, Is a ‘Step Backwards’ From Sarah Connor

What to Stream Now See what's new and notable on Netflix, Amazon, Hulu, and HBO

It Was Brad Pitt’s Nudes, Specifically, That Didn’t Impress Shania Twain Much

 Criticism Saying ‘There is No Right and Wrong Kind of Powerful Woman’

’ Season-7 Finale Will Be Its Longest Episode Ever — and It Has a Curious Title

Nocturnal Animals Has Two Endings, and Both of Them Are Killer

“I believe women can and should be everything male lead characters should be.”

Hear Taylor Swift’s New Song, ‘Look What You Made Me Do’

’s Music Soars Where Its Narrative Falters

Kim Kardashian Appears to Have Blocked the Snake Emoji in Response to Taylor

Somewhere, Taylor Swift is hissing with glee.

This YA Book Got Pulled from The Bestseller List for Allegedly Gaming The System

made a surprise appearance at No. 1 on the Young Adult Hardcover list despite little evidence of sales.

Donna Tartt’s campus thriller is my personal Platonic ideal of what a novel should be.

trainer about how, exactly, we (and Zac) got here.

If you love spooky costume dramas, don’t miss

It Was Brad Pitt’s Nudes, Specifically, That Didn’t Impress Shania Twain Much

“I mean what is all the fuss. We see people naked every day.”

It’s basically a CBS sitcom that smoked a little weed.

, Director Eliza Hittman Shows Male Sexuality Her Way

Who gets to tell what story? “I don’t think people should be limited.”

Halsey Considers John Mayer a ‘Comedic Genius,’ Sometimes Runs Jokes by Him

Lady Gaga’s Netflix Doc Promises an Intimate Look at a Year in Her Life

It’ll premiere first at the Toronto Film Festival, then hit Netflix on September 22.

Eliza Hittman’s story of a Coney Island bro questioning his sexuality is at its best when focusing on mood over plot.

post to your social media account without your permission.

Please follow the instructions in the email within 48 hours to complete your registration.

Enter your email address or username and we’ll email instructions on how to reset your password.

This username or email is associated with a Facebook account.

We’ve sent you an email with instructions on how to reset your password.

Your username will appear next to your comments.

You already have an account registered under . You can link your Facebook account to your existing account.

Welcome! You are now a registered user of NYMag.com, TheCut.com, Vulture.com, ScienceOfUs.com and GrubStreet.com.

We\'re sorry. You must confirm your registration within 48 hours of submitting your registration request. Please register again.