\'Game of Thrones\' showrunners on season 4 finale twists
Warning: Game of Thrones finale spoilers below…
concluded season 4 with its strongest finale yet, which is exactly what showrunners David Benioff and Dan Weiss promised last week. In fact, the duo were so proud of this hour, it’s the only episode this season that they are are submitting for Emmy consideration in the writing category. Below the showrunners talk about a few of the finale’s twists and turns, with more to come tomorrow.
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Let’s talk The Hound fighting Brienne. What inspired that clash?
David Benioff: It felt right to us, these two pairings: The Hound and Arya; Brienne and Pod. Both are on quests. The Hound is trying to get Arya to the Eyrie; Brienne is trying to find the Stark girls. It felt right to us that those quests would collide at end of season.
Dan Weiss: The Hound and Brienne are two people who, by the time we get them together, you’re sort of rooting for both of them, in a way. Brienne is obviously a more moral character than The Hound. But I would hope you can’t help but love The Hound in spite of yourself, a little bit. The idea they’re both going to try tooth and nail and sword to kill each other, there’s something classically epic about it. You got Achilles fighting Hector — there isn’t a good guy and a bad guy, it’s two people you’re both extremely invested in and there’s a fascination and horror of knowing that one of them is inevitably going to get the worst of this situation.
Shooting that pivotal privy scene must have been intense.
Weiss: Oh yeah. Gotta be the most intense toilet scene ever shot.
Benioff: It was a great scene in the book and a way to see them in their final scene together. It was rough because Charles [Dance] is just a phenomenon. And he’s been amazing in every single scene he’s had — from cleaning the stag with Jaime in season one up until his privy death. To have the privilege to write for an actor of that caliber and then to know it’s over is a huge honor and incredibly depressing.
Weiss: He’s one of those people, maybe more than anyone we’re working with, that cliche is true that they’re “so good the dialog writes itself.” When you’re sitting down to write a Tywin scene it’s almost like you’re not having to do any work, it’s like he’s making his words exactly the way they need to be in your head and all you have to do is type them down because he brings such a power and specificity to everything he does. Writing for him is pure pleasure.
Does it worry you to lose your two best villains in the show this season?
Weiss: Well, I don’t think Tywin is a villain.
Benioff: That’s a fair point. If you read the story from Stark point of view–
Weiss: — then I guess he would be a villain–
Benioff: But Tywin isn’t torturing prostitutes for pleasure. He’s not sadist. He’s ruthless, for sure. But there’s an argument to be made that Westeros needs ruthlessness. You look at Daenerys across the sea — she’s crucifying 163 masters; she’s pretty ruthless too. So you love Daenerys even when she’s killing people and condemn Tywin. I think somebody asked Charles about that in an interview and he was quite resistant to the idea of Tywin as a villain. I think Dan’s right. I don’t think of him as evil.
Game of Thrones season 4 finale showrunners interview continues. This portion was recently conducted via email with replies attributed to both Benioff and Weiss…
First, that mammoth in episode 9: Can you talk about adding this new creature?
Benioff & Weiss: The wooly mammoths were an element from the book that we desperately wanted on the show and for a long time didn’t think we could afford. Figuring out how to create them fell upon our brilliant but overworked VFX department, chiefly Steve Kullback and Joe Bauer. A number of notions were tossed around, including the possibility of putting a giant wig on an elephant (no, I’m not joking). In the end the creatures were completely CGI and another Steve/Joe triumph.
We lost a Reed in the finale! You couldn’t have possibly thought: “Well, not enough characters died this season,” so can you address that move?
Jojen is a bit like John the Baptist. He’s there to make sure a person of cosmic importance ends up where he belongs. Once Bran gets to the Three-Eyed Raven, he has served his greater purpose. It felt right to have him sacrifice himself to get Bran to his destination. Also, there are lot of wights in that frozen field. It seemed pretty unlikely they wouldn’t score at least once.
Is there any major character who has perished on the show that you gave serious consideration to sparing (and if so, what was the scenario by which they might have lived)?
We did not want to kill [Dothraki horserider] Rakharo, but Elyes Gabel got some excellent offers for bigger roles and we knew we were losing him. So rather than have him disappear from the show we decided to put his head in a saddlebag.
I know better than to ask if The Hound is dead, but: Can you tease us anything about what to expect from Brienne’s storyline in 5 now that she’s been through this unexpected event?
You can expect that she’ll remain irritated with Pod for some time to come.
One thread this season is that several popular characters took dark turns. Many of the younger characters have learned hard lessons from past horrors. David, you’ve talked about how a supreme’s being’s justice doesn’t really manifest in George’s world, that all justice is man-made. So I guess my question is, after Ned Stark and the Red Wedding and so forth, is the lesson that needs to be learned by “The Children” (Dany, Jon, Arya, Sansa, etc) that they must be mean, unfair, brutal to survive? And that altruism, honesty and empathy are essentially foolish virtues? And if so, are we just talking about George’s world here, or are we talking about our own, too? This is sort of a philosophical question — perhaps I should have asked Jack Gleeson — but I wonder if in this sprawling epic tale that appears to have no center or theme — you guys always note when trying to think of a unifying theme for each season that such characterizations are too trite … Could this be what this story is actually about?
As you say, we try to resist that reductive urge to summarize the season with a single sentence. But that doesn’t mean the series lacks a center, and it’s right there in the title. The game of thrones features women and men vying for power while the powerless try to avoid getting squashed underfoot. No one can protect you, neither gods nor family nor friends. You have to fend for yourself — and even then you might get your throat cut.
We wouldn’t say that the characters you mention have rejected morality. Dany tries desperately to be just, even while dealing with viciously unjust opponents. Jon Snow tries to live with honor, while knowing that honor often gets his family members murdered. And et cetera. But a lot of this story — this season especially — is about people learning to face hard truths about the world they live in, and adapt themselves to those truths. The struggle many of them face is how to do that without losing their grip on who they are. Whether or not they succeed… well, people will have to decide for themselves. This season many characters’ undergo drastic changes in their own identities, and are forced to reevaluate how they see themselves and their places in the world.
showrunners tomorrow with Part 2 of this interview, teasing up season 5…
Lorne Michaels: \'SNL\' cast changes ahead
'Nurse Jackie' recap: Jackie's fire sale Michelle Newman, Community Contributor
Catch up with 'General Hospital': weekly recap Karen Belgrad, Community Contributor
'In the Flesh' season finale react: With life comes death TeamTSD, Community Contributor
Host Alex Trebek Sets a Guinness World Record
Jimmy Fallon, Chris Christie Boogie Through the Evolution of Dad Dancing
Viral Vid: Thrones\' Hodor on Family Feud
A Tribute to Casey Kasem, Kelly Clarkson\'s New Addition & More Weekend News
Kris Jenner Sends a Sweet First Birthday Message to Granddaughter North West
Poachers Kill Satao, One of the World\'s Largest Elephants
Anne Hathaway & Adam Shulman Spotted with New Puppy
Woman Travels with Life-Size Cutout of Her Late Father to the Places He Never Saw
Amy Van Dyken Is Sitting Up, Smiling One Week After Severing Her Spine
'Pretty Little Liars' Star's Latest Magazine Shoot Is Definitely Not PG-13
Kendall Jenner Somehow Managed To Make A Turtleneck Racy
'Game Of Thrones' Star Didn't Know His Real Name Until He Was 11
14 Netflix Movies To Watch With Dad This Father's Day
This Week\'s Cover: Channing Tatum and Jonah Hill return for another action-packed round in
. But what they really want to be? Hollywood\'s cutest couple.
, here\'s a list of our fifty favorite scenes from the past year. (Emmy voters, take note.)
, a slew of dearly departed projects are finding new lives.
Father\'s Day: Author Brad Meltzer on dads who changed history
Wonder Woman returns in digital \'Sensation Comics\' issue: See the cover
Juan Gabriel Vasquez wins IMPAC award
What We\'re Reading Now: \'China Dolls\' by Lisa See
Kevin Kwan on \'Crazy Rich Asians\' sequel, movie
Box office report: \'22 Jump Street\' is the big winner; \'How to Train Your Dragon 2\' solid #2
\'How to Train Your Dragon 2\': Is Gobber really gay? -- SPOILERS
Box office update: \'22 Jump Street\' in early lead with $25M Friday
Casting Net: Maya Rudolph reunites with Tina Fey, Amy Poehler
Fans crowdfund imaginary Foo Fighters concert; band agrees to play it
Casey Kasem, famed radio DJ and voice actor, has died at 82
Summerland Tour preview: Everclear\'s Art Alexakis on playing the hits and choosing food over sex