OOoh. I'd have to say a 7 for the movie and a 10 for the book. but im a suckah for books > movies.

i havent read the book, but im giving the movie a 100 out of 10. :P

I would give the book a 9, and the movie a 10. I love Tim Burton's films, so I have to give it a ten.

ooooh hard. Probably 91/ for both of them.

9 for the movie 8 for the book.