duh duh duh duh duh D-U-H!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D

If zach efron was edward I would be so mad...

i would Die if zac efron became edward, it would ruin the whole movie, and i Hated high school musical so no way will zac be in the twilight movie!!!!!!!

Efron annnnnnnoys me!

well of course it is duh spunky 100 % I mean yeah zac is a cute little kid but leave him to the singing and dancing if you want a good actor I pick a real man.

Zac Efron is kinda good looking (but no where near as much as S Ransom!) but he has the WORST personality EVER! Rob is a sweetie pie!

zac is a fake cuz they blended his voice and everything in high school musical. plus yah EVERYTHING HIGH SCHOOL MUSICAL RELATED SUX!!!!! i would burn down the producer's door if zac was edward totally!!

okay no way would i watch the movie if ZAC EFRON was playing edward, omg zac save your self for the musicals alright ?

I honeslty can't stand Zac, I mean no offence to anyone and it's my opinion, but I hate High School Musical, I've spared myself from watching it and I never plan to watch. How much make up does that kid use?!?! I won't let my little sister mention anything HSM related within a mile radius of me or else I hit her, I hate it sooooo much!!

I agree with cowgirlfromhell, except I won't hit my sisters if they mention anything about HSM. But, I still can't stand those songs and movies.

I agree with cowgirlfromhell I hate HSM with a PASSION it is stupid bullshit just like Hannah Montanna, and other shows like that are killing kids brains and turning them into mush!!! GO SPUNK!!

ZACK EFRON EWWWWWWWWWWWWWWwww it would ruin everything. high school mucical wasnt great and if the movie director people picked him i would never ever see the movie. HE SUCKS bye the way whoever picked zack effron has serious mental issues

Whaaat!. Phineas anf Ferb are great! no really, have you watched and episode? It's hilarious! But I agree, Disney's pretty much gine downhill. And hell NO! Zac Efron isn't, and will probably never be close enough to pull this part off. I'm bet money to say, only Robert could do it!!!

WHAT? How the hell can you compare Robert Pattinson to fuckin Zac Efron?

i was just takin 2 major heartthrobs graceful_alice. i mean zac is relly popular and so is zac and i just was curious...but rob is definetly better, just curious what the overall responce to this would b...

zac efron would RUIN the movie for me

is Spunky was in Harry Potter the guy who died

yeah he was :)

i HATE zac...he is so...gey-lookin...

Zac's too pretty

I used to love Zac , but I got over it ;)

same here.

Ok, I understand that you don´t like Zac, but gooshh! Leave him alone then!!!!!
If you don´t like him then don´t humiliate him. Please,Sure he doesn´t fit in the role of Edward Cullen, because he could never be soo serious! He really has an amazing voice.
P.S. I used to love Twilight But I Got Over It!!!
And to chocolette or Whateverr.. If someone likes Zac, It doesn´t mean he/she has some serious mental issues!!! People just iike different things. In fact, I could never love someone Like Robert,he has terrible personality-- Ewww

im not a huge fan of robert pattinson but ew.. zac efron :P

Idiots!
Zac's cool

i could never love someone who loves robert, he has such a crap personality and is really ugly!!!!!!!!!

zac, on the other hand....too perfect!!!!!!!

i would choose rob pattison over zac any day. and i like rob's personality he would be cool and fun to hang out with. so i disagree with you.