In terms of Twilight, anyway. I haven't seen any of Chris' other films, and I've seen Catherine's film Thirteen and that's incredible.

Way better.

He did the best job, personally. Catherine had set the bar, but Chris jumped over it ten-fold!

yea, New Moon over Twilight.

He's definetly better than Catherine. New Moon over Twilight.

It is hard to decide, Catherine did a great job with Twilight, getting the us to see and feel the Love and the desire that Bella and Edward had for each other, and I feel that she did a great job. Chris also did a great job. He stayed true to the book, he still kept the love between Bella and Edward and brought us into the new desire with Jacob. I just wish that New Moon would have been longer!!!

Chris. Hands down.
I think that Catherine did a good job with Twilight, but so much was left out! There were many things that I wish weren't in there and things from the book that I wish were.
New Moon was almost perfect! If I could talk to Chris, I'd bow to him! lol! (Not really, but I'd thank him a lot)

she was awful and twilight was awful.

Its obvious.
And yes let me just add-She was absolutely awful and the movie was lame.

hands down, Chris Weitz is a MUCH better director!! I think the script for new moon was better as well. David Slade who's directing Eclipse is an AMAZING director so that film should be awesome too!

Chris because well I liked New Moon better,Twilight there was so much left out and did not meet my expectations.