your question is closed

huh?

As long as he keeps his mask on he's as hot as they come! lol

I think that even with the deformity, he is very appealing. And there's more to people than their appearance...

God no. Mask or not, he's beautiful in my eyes.

He is the hottest gut I've seen.Even without his mask I still think he is HOT!!!

How could anyone think he was ugly - even with his mask off?

If he keeps his mask on and his black wig he is good looking

he's got too much inner beauty to be ugly

as long as he keeps the mask on. plus the mask makes you concentrate on his sexy mouth when he talks and sings ;)

I agree with WritersMelody, and thats something Christine and the rest of them ddnt take notice on, they just went omg his face is distorted! he must be such a terrible person! thats what gets me mad

it actually annoys me that his deformity isn't that bad looking. When his mask is first taken off it looks bad but in less harsh lighting in the very next seen he is still good looking, althought not comparable to his first full appearance to Christine with his mask on...wow...

he is H-O-T HOT!!! but if he takes his mask off not so really

Gerard Butler is one of those guys who just leaves you in awe with his beauty.
Even when he had his mask off I was drooling over him!
haha

Well, if we're talking Gerik, no, he's not. Even though he's supposed to be hideously deformed!! He's still hot! And he's not supposed to have a nose!

*stands in corner and rants to self*

Gerry, yes, hot of course lol. The actor in the musical I saw wasn't fantastic looking. He's not supposed to be though that's the whole deal. He's torn between anger at society, complete shame of his appearance and love and selfishness. Definitely a beautiful character. <3 <3 <3

Let's put it this way---being stuck in a cave with HIM would definitely NOT be bad!!!

Definitely not ugly!

Gerard Butler could never be ugly in my eyes. ;)

*Stands there being totally unimpressed with Gerard Butler* The man can't sing! He sounds like a moose! And while he's not ugly, he's not my version of hot. *Has had issues with Gerry since he f***ed up Dracula*
In the book, well. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder. And my corpsey Erik is incredibly dear to me. I don't think I could ever see him as truly ugly.

I happen to think that Phantom is ugly. Dunno why, really

He just looks a bit sunburned in the movie, which makes the seen where Bouquet describes severity of the Leroux-phantom hilarious. That and Butler can't sing, a annoys me to no ends.

I guess it depends on which Phantom you're referring to. If it's the 2004 movie, then no. But if you're talking about it in reality or in general, then yes, because he is suppose to be ugly -- that's the whole point of the story and what made Erik who he is.

...it's kind of the point. I don't consider him 'hot' or 'pretty' but I find him adorably sexy in a creepy stalker way. But he's corpse-y, guys. Would I do him? Totally. Do I consider him hot? Nope. Besides, it's the voice that matters here. ;)

In the 2004 movie yes

His Dark Sexuality is just Immence! xx

This man is SEXY mask on or off.

hell no! he's gorgeous!

he's amazing

Er.... well that is the point...
2004 movie obviously Joel Schumacher didn't get that.. idiot..
I think it does depend on the version, the musical isn't really that bad, but sacrifices needed to be made so they actor could actually sing..
Obviously the book has more options than a movie or musical to describe it.. But the for '04 movie the technology they had on offer they could have created that character..

no(only when he is angry)

yeah of course he is, Christine even describes him as "smelling like death, and having a skeleton head" doesn't sound attractive to me. But at least he can sing...

No, beauty lies inside. :-)

On the outside, of course he is. You were not referring to Gerard Butler, right?

Depends on which movie.

However, "handsome" is more polite than "sexy"

hes soooooo hot!

He is beautiful inside, right?

I think he's sort of 'HOT' both on the inside and outside too!

Every actor who is honored to do this part is BEAUTIFUL.

Depends on which version but in the 2004 movie no he was handsome even with the disfigurement he was also beautiful on the inside besides the mental issues he had,I always wondered what if Christine would of picked him instead of raoul.

no