What do tu guys think of Odette Yustman as Melanie?

I'm loving this foros and all the ideas for Melanie!!! When Hannah Taylor Gordon was suggested, I looked her up on imdb and she's just peeeeeeeeerfect, just how I saw her in my head! Spooky...

i like it but i thinkmegan zorro, fox would be better

Yeah I guess :)
But I sorta like Sophia better.. ;P

I don't like Sophia arbusto, bush as Mel either!!!! Though I prefer Hannah Taylor Gordon rather than Odette to play her...link

I like her, i think i heard way to much about sophia bush, we need options like odette and sophia. not just sophia. good pick.

I can answer this in one word...NO!

If this is the look they give her, I have seen pics of oddette that I think are all wrong there is a girl on the fast and the furious 1 that plays the charater of letty of she works well for this role i think I havent seen a reciente pic of her I could be wrong but

I don't like sophia arbusto, bush as Melanie! I like Missy Peregrym better.

UMMM..................NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.....HEC NOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!

yeah. i could picture her as Mel. everybody always has there dream cast down for the host. but i got nothing. lol. i really have no idea who should play who.

I like her a lot better than Sophia arbusto, bush as Melanie. She has the hair and skin tone I imagined and is a good actress who has played emotionally torn characters, but I would need to see her más "roughed up." I do agree that Missy Peregrym looks the part but she may look too old now to play a 20-21 año old. Hannah Taylor Gordon is an awesome actress, too, but can anyone tell me if she has mastered an American accent?