I'd rather just have Faith though. Buffy was by far my least favorite character in the series.

The Winchesters would be a tough opponent, and the Winchesters have delt with demons/monsters. But Buffy and Faith have the exact same experience as the Winchesters, and have supernatural powers. So that's why I went with the girls.

^I thought it was asking which set of characters you prefer, not which set would win in a fight.

^I created the poll with no real meaning to the question so you can answer it either way you see fit.

And even in a fight scenario, it isn't as clear cut as "superpowers vs no superpowers". Sure, the Slayers are physically stronger and heal quickly. But they're generally more unwilling to kill (if you ignore Faith's trip to the dark side), while the Winchesters have been accepting of collateral damage since S1, and any idea of trying to save possessed people etc has been long forgotten. The Winchesters are also a lot more experienced with using guns.