i haven't heard the deluxe edition, so i stick with the stuff i know

major tie! too good a band to judge their albums individually.

THERE ALL GOOD.ALL OF THERE SONGS I LIKE.GOD GIVE THEM REALY NICE AND GOOD TALENT.

I have this cd.

yea i like this one better the acoustics and the bonus Live Free Or Let Me Die is a great song too ^^

comatose is the only cd i have, i just started listening 2 them cuz my friend liked them but now i loooove them

I love comatose, I have all their CD's and my favorite song is whispers in the dark!!!

i haven't heard the delux edition yet

both r awesome

john coo-per is HOT i mean really

both :D

I would say tie, but then I would probably be lying... I don't really know, i swear I love both albums, but I kinda think I like Comatose just a little bit more... ._.