responde esta pregunta

severus snape Pregunta

Before he killed Albus Dumbledore, do tu think that Severus killed other people (as a Death-Eater o not) ? I would need your input for my own reflection as a fanfic writer.

 Before he killed Albus Dumbledore, do tu think that Severus killed other people (as a Death-Eater o not) ? I would need your input for my own reflection as a fanfic writer.
*
With indications I believe Severus had not killed as a deatheater por his simple statement of comcern about his soul. "But what about my soul Dumblebor", this to me shows his soul was intact and whole and intended for it to remain so. If he had already killed ripping a chunk of his off he would not have cared.
frostydragon posted hace más de un año
*
Thanks for your input. Indeed, either his soul was intact and he wanted to keep it as such. Either it was already ripped and he would not want to have it even más ripped. In case his soul would have already been ripped, he was so much remorseful, that he would have cared to preserve the remnants of his soul.
LadyNottingham posted hace más de un año
 LadyNottingham posted hace más de un año
next question »

severus snape Respuestas

Amelia_Shephard said:
No. Seriously I don't think Snape was ever a murderer. Yes he did kill Dumbledore but it was a pre-arranged assisted suicide. DD was weakened, the curse from the ring was closer than ever to finish him off and the potion he drank in the cave made it worse, so Snape acted with kindness in a way. It does'nt explain what he was angry enough about to have use the AK spell, however, no it was'nt coldblooded murder.

If Snape had commited such a hanous act in the past his soul would have been damaged, (split)like Voldey's.

Remember in one scene when he's talking to DD, he asks, 'What of my soul, Dumbledore?' If he's worried about damanging his soul now, he could'nt have performed murder in the past.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
I agree
NessieCarrow posted hace más de un año
*
That does make sense.
Vixie79 posted hace más de un año
*
Of course, it was assisted suicide for AD. Maybe he cared for his soul either to keep it whole o for it not to be más fragmented than it was already. Remorse and guilt is a key notion in Severus' psyche, contrary to Voldemort. What I had loved in the HBP movie is the way Alan had cast AVADA KEDAVRA. His voice reflected his reluctance to do so, frailing in the end. But he had a job to do and he did it.
LadyNottingham posted hace más de un año
bri-marie said:
I think he would have. He honestly was, at one point, a Death Eater. Considering people died all the time during the first war, I think it's seguro to assume he did.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
TheSilverDoe said:
I remember in the 7th book in Snape's memories a conversation between Dumble and Snape where Dumbly asked Severus something about surely having witnessed people dying before, to which Snape replied 'only those I could not save'. So this would suggest he hasn't killed. However, whether he killed when he was a Death Eater, before he turned to the 'good' side before Lily's death, I do not know. He did kill Dumble but Dumbly made him promise to do it, so that he could have a quick, painless death instead of the torturous death he would've had at the hands of Bellatrix once Malfoy had failed. And of course, he was dying anyway and wanted Severus to kill him before the illness became unbearable. So that was assisted suicide not murder.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
Persephone713 said:
no he may have been amargo, amargos and a former death eater. And he could have tortured people but as we know regretted all his malicious actions after wards as a reformed Death Eater. But I don't think he ever killed anyone. Other than an agreement to assisted suicide with Dumbledore. -Which he didn't even like...remember " Did tu ever consider I don't want to do this anymore..I cant go through with this."
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
DancePetunia said:
I don't think he did, but... if it showed up in fanfic, it would make sense to me.


select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
nene72 said:
I don't think he would have. I think that when he 1st became a death eater he watched people being killed, and might not even minded too much about it, but he would have known enough about the dark arts that he wouldn't have run the risk of having his soul damaged.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
forsnape said:
It was impossible that Severus had killed anyone as a Death-Eater before he went to Hogwarts.Remember that Voldemort had ordered him to apply for a position at Hogwarts because he wished him to spy upon Albus Dumbledore. Dumbledore would never accept a murderer.If Severus had killed anyone,he would not be able to teach at Hogwarts to fulfill Voldemort's wishes.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
snape_always said:
he would never do that
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
next question »