I mean seriousely ppl keep saying "Brooke doesn't deserve Peyton's Leftovers." And I think it's really silly, I mean he is a human not a half-eaten sandwhich. If you want to get technical then why does Julian (Who seems like a great guy) keep having to have Lucas's Leftovers? I mean he's been with Peyton and now Brooke. I just think it's silly. I mean obviousely Brooke and Peyton have the same taste in men. And it's not like all the guys Brooke has dated have been with Peyton first, I mean Nick, Felix, Owen,and Chase didn't date Peyton first. And yet ppl are reacting like all Brooke gets is the men Peyton dumps and that is just not true.
AND if you want to get REALLY techinical, Peyton is engaged to Brooke's Leftovers!
Sorry to rant I just really have found this "leftover" thing to be ridiculous, it was silly when Brooke said it in S4 and it's even more silly now....IMO.

LMFAO Ellies totally agree it's freakin retarded he is NOT her leftovers!!!! Brooke and Lindsey aren't Lucas's leftovers, Jake and Pete aren't Peytons!! They are humans people NOT food!

I agree! :)

yes it is, as I said before they are BFF they just attract the same type of guys. Some people are just spoiling for a fight.

It's not okay, but i still don't know Julian's intentions and he seems to be in love with Peyton still.

If Julian never stared at his Juton picture in secret and played games with Leyton then I wouldn't think of it that way. It's not the fact that Peyton dated Julian, it's the fact that he still seems hung up on her and I don't trust him yet. Nor do I think he's in any position to be in a new relationship right now. He hasn't healed yet. So until I'm confident that he's separated himself emotionally from Peyton, I still consider him "not yet whole", therefore "leftovers." But that's just my opinion.

i think it's just the fact that Brooke KEEPS dating guys that have been previously attached to Peyton that gets on my nerves. so yes, in this case... i do consider Julian to be Peyton's leftovers. and just for the record... Lucas was attached to/into Peyton BEFORE he was attached to/into Brooke, which means that he is PEYTON'S leftovers, NOT Brooke's. saying that Peyton is engaged to Brooke's leftovers is ridiculous..... because it was definitely Lucas and Peyton BEFORE it was Lucas and Brooke

Lucas IS Brooke's leftovers though =]. LOL no it is a little silly..who called him that?

i'll gladly admit that I have called Julian Peyton's leftovers on a couple different occasions, because he IS her leftovers. i think i said something along the lines of "i like Brooke and Julian, but at the same time it would be nice to see Brooke with someone OTHER than Peyton's leftovers for a change" (which is true) :)

Well then can't the same thing be said about Lucas? If Brooke's with Peyton's leftovers then Peyton is with Brooke's.

Nope not really....but when he's with Brooke i don't think of it that way i just think of Brook and Julian - i only think of him that way as a character. But the more he's on screen the less i'll think of him that way.

he is her leftoevers but not in the sense like omg brooke cant have peytons leftovers blah blah its because technically it is like they were together it didnt work out

and i would class lucas ans brookes leftovers yeh leyton were linked before brucas but not enough to be classed as leftovers i was linked to one of my friends boyfriends and i dont class it as that there wasnt enought there both in my case and leytons first case to class it as leftovers just stating my point =)

oh but i would say that julian has had BOTH of lucases leftovers

OMG I LOVE YOU LINDSEY! :O
I love the way you write, I love you're comments! You're A GODDESS! <3

*PROPS PROPS PROPS PROPS*

Thank anetted and TrinaA you both Rock!

erm i agree with the option yes .. but lucas isnt brookes leftovers .. peyton had him before brooke did :s

but yeah i dont think it matters peyton had julian first - brulian are hot <3 inlove with them!

at first i was thinking like that but after 6x14 i dont anymore!!i like Brulian and i dont consider Julian as a leftover..i like the "ex" sound better!!and somehow i dont find it at all weird that Brooke is now "dating" Peyton's ex..the only thing im worried about is that what abs said that Julian seems to care still for Peyton but im hoping that he wont do something stupid!!HE BETTER NOT!!

p.s i dont agree with Brooke being Luca's leftover

It fits him well

and no one ever calls Chase as Brooke's leftover, I guess it's just a case of Brooke vs. Peyton.

Just a reminder that Brooke in 4x08 called Lucas her leftovers. And Brooke dated many guys after Peyton: Lucas, Nathan, Julian. They certainly share a lot of guys