Sorry, but Haley. :(
I would HATE it, but i can't pick Nathan. I love him too much..

NO-ONE!!!

I don't like this question.
I'm not picking :)

I can't answer this, sorry

no way. no comment.
gads!

This pick is cruel and mean!! I refuse to pick!!! I think that if they were gonna die it would be both of them cause they can't live without each other.They are always and forever...and without both parts of a whole the other would be incomplete and probably die right along with them.

You guys are right, none of them should die! If that ever happened the next one to die would be Mark! :@
But i always answer all the picks, even the hard ones where i really can't choose..
So don't be mad at me for picking Haley. I DON'T want her to die! I love her, she is a part of Naley and she brings so much to the show. I only had two options to choose, Haley or Nathan..
And like i said, i can't pick him.. :(
But if something like that ever happened to Haley, Nathan would be misereble. Like mcewen_girl said, they can't leave withouth each other.

lol, i don't think ellie-scott asked this to be cruel or something. It's just a pick.
It would never happen, thank God for that. :D

I agree with mcewen_girl...I refuse to pick!

SORRY GUYS!!!! just tryin 2 c who ppl like more nate or haley dats all!!

i wont pick, but IF one of them were 2 die i think it could b hales. 'cause nate is all stron nad tough!!

I don't know.. But I think it would be Haley... sorry guys.
But none of them should die!

I won't pick either, I love both character so much. Why does a Nate or Hales have to die, why not Lucas?

If I have to pick...is Nathan, I like Haley better
but still dont want any of them to die!!!

you cowards suck it up and pick.... much thought went into mine...all through season 4 and back i would have picked haley to die ..(cept when she was pregnant of course)

but at the moment i am a bit sick of nathans storyline... i'm awesome at basketball... i'm not allowed to plays basketball... i suck at bascket ball... wait a minute someones done something inspirational n suddenly ... what heck yes i'm awesome at basketball again... but wait they all think i'm crippled so now i cant play...

ok i do love nathan he is prob one of my fave characters but i picked for jamie... i know it's sexist but i think he needs his mum... he does idolize his dad yes butfor months haley took care of him on her own and i don't think there would be a strong enough mother for himn if she died... brooke is gorgeous and would make a great mum but she was away from jamie when he was younger... and lucas has always been there and i know he couldnt replace nathan but it'd be closer then brooke stepping in for haley....
ok so now i'm almost talking myself out of the decision... lol... this is mean but meh, lol

i do love nathan
let's just have luke or peyton die instead

IF I HAD TO PICK...Nathan..xD

damn no way I refuse

brathan

I refuse to pick too

I cant.

Aw, I don't like that pick >.<
But if I had to I'd choose Haley. Nathan would be devestated for years but he still has some options. And he has Jamie and I think they'd help each other a lot.
I can't imagine Haley with someone else EVER. Or just alone (with Jamie) for that matter.