Thank you everyone for your contributions!
I really like this and misanthrope86 (1).

I actually like most of these! Was hard to choose! I wasn't gonna vote for my own lol!
I think this would make a nice icon. This is my choice!

Uh... so how long are these picks going to be open for? We have a problem here in that with the banner pick and icon pick running simultaneously is that we are almost certain to have an icon and banner combination that don't even remotely match... I won't be able to vote for an icon until I know which banner has won, so that I can pick one of the icons that matches it...

For now I've picked the icon that matches the banner choice I made... some of us might have to change our votes once we know which banner has won...

^ Let's see which icon & banner are going to be the popular one and from there we can narrow down further by setting up 2nd round, etc.

I guess that is an option. Hopefully we will get matching things into a second round.

While it is nice to have a matching banner and icon I feel that it isn't necessary because all banners and icons are relevant and most likely if a banner and icon go together it was probably made by the same person so if a winning banner was by 1 person and the winning icon was by another person that would be nice because then 2 people get to have their contribution displayed. I hope that makes sense! Hopefully nobody would take offense at this as I am only stating my opinion! As I feel the original winners feelings would be hurt just because the icon and banner don't match that there would be a re vote! I would feel bad for that to happen to someone! It just doesn't seem fair.

It isn't about hurting people's feelings. It is about making the club look good. A good, cohesive spot look helps the club and Fanpop in general gain users. Icons and banners that don't match very rarely look good. That doesn't mean that someone has made a bad icon or banner, it just means an icon and a banner can look good individually, but not together. There isn't much point in 2 people having their contributions up there if it makes the spot look bad. And again, I'm not saying that the individual contributions look bad, but that they won't necessarily look good together.

You should have had the banner and icon from each person voted on as a set. No matter what the way you are talking about doing the voting, somebody's feelings are going to be hurt and that is not right!!! I think any of the icons will look great with any of the banners!!! They are all Katy!!!!!! It is about hurting peoples feelings!!!!!!!!!!! Cause everybody took the time to make their banners and icons and they should not have their win taken from them cause the banner and icon supposedly don't match!!! They all match!!!!!!!

Oof.

Isn't it about what all the members of the club like? Not about hurting people's feelings? I mean, if you're gonna get your feelings hurt, why did you bother making a banner and icon? You know that you're not guaranteed to have yours be the club look. Well anyway, I think the banner and icon that DarkSarcasm made are amazing.