responde esta pregunta

harry potter Pregunta

When the prophecy said.."he'll've power Darklord knows not"..do u think it refers to ElderWand's ownership that Harry work out after Doby's death. Only Harry knew who is the true owner...not amor as Dumbledore told

 Bibelot posted hace más de un año
next question »

harry potter Respuestas

tototo19 said:
No, I believe not. The Elder Wand is, I think, irrelevant for this matter, because it wasn't even once mentioned in the fifth book, none of us knew anything about it, and so didn't J.K., I believe. The Elder Wand is a powerful wand, but as we all know, Harry and Voldemort never had a duel. At least not a real one...
Harry had a truly powerful weapon, and, as Dumbledore dicho so, it is love. I hardly believe J.K. would make a mistake in the last book, that she wouldn't explain it right. She knew what she was writing, and if she dicho it is love, then I believe it is love...Because Voldemort wasn't able to love, he had no mercy, and so Harry knew what he would become, and that's why he tried to convince Voldemort to feel pity and regret for what he had done; Harry knew Voldemort wouldn't come back if he died without any Horcruxes bonding him to this life. That was Harry's true weapon, the one that cursed Voldemort to a weak, non - existent creature we had the opportunity to see in DH, that creature under the chair that Harry felt so sorry for in the beginning...It is all love!!!
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
Dunno, that's how I understood the book. Could be I'm wrong though:)
tototo19 posted hace más de un año
*
u dicho everything i wanted to say! :)
Irina92 posted hace más de un año
*
Oh man...the prophecy clearly dicho that "he knows the power dark lord knows not" and voldemort , after possessing harry in OOTP, then knew that harry has power of amor and after that he fears to possess harry due to this reason. What he did not know was who is the true owner of elder wand. Only harry knew who is the true owner of elder wand. This was dumbledore's "idea" that that secret was amor and we know that sometimes even he made mistakes.
Bibelot posted hace más de un año
PotterFanatic said:
I think all of tu who have answered this pregunta are wrong.
before answering the pregunta i would like tu to read the following,
Harry: tu cant torture them, tu cant touch them, tu dont learn from your mistakes Riddle
Voldy: tu Dare?
H: Yes i dare because i know things that tu do not, Tom Riddle.Want to hear some of them before tu make another big mistake?
V: Is t amor again? Dumbuldores Favourite solution love.................................no one seems to amor enough potter then what will stop youdying tu now when i strike
H: Just one thing
V: If it is not amor that will save tu potter Then tu must believe that tu have magic that i do not,or else a weapon más powerful than mine
H: i believe both
.................................................
.................................................
.................................................
.................................................
V: dumbuldore was trying to keep the elder wand from me................And the DEATHSTICK, THE ELDER WAND, THE WAND OF DESTINY,is truly mine!
Dumbuldores last plan went wrong, Harry Potter!
H: Yeah it did , tu are right..........Be a man try....try for some remorse ........
V: tu Dare-?
H: Yes i dare, Bcoz dumbuldores last plan is not Backfired on me, its backfired on tu riddle....
................................Severus snape was not true master of elder wand. He never defeated Dumbuoldore.
V: He killed-
H: Arent tu listening? Snape never beat Dumbuldore ................................
The true master of wand was Draco Malfoy.
V: ........................................After i have killed tu i can attend Draco Malfoy
H: But tu are too late, tu missed your chance.I got there first. I overpowered Draco weeks ago. I took this wand from him.................... I am the true master of elder wand



Now note these points
When voldy asked harry that is it amor again?, Harry dicho no
Harry dicho i know things that tu donot and then explained that how harry himself is the master of Elder Wand
Soooooooooooooo!!!!!!! My dear ones it was obviously the elder wand....
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
read my answer... u may find it interesting..
Irina92 posted hace más de un año
*
I really found ur answer interesting coz i didnt got a single word of it.You didnt made yourself clear
PotterFanatic posted hace más de un año
*
I think you're soooooooo wrong! Seriously, Dumbledore didn't even know in the 5th part he was going to die. So there was no big plan to give Harry the Elder wand. And if tu remember, Dumbledore didn't even want Harry to have the Elder wand. He wanted Snape to be the real master....It's just a matter of fact that Harry was the real Master of Death, it wasn'teven mentioned in the 5th part that there is such a powerful wand! The prophecy never mantioned some wand, nor did J.K.
tototo19 posted hace más de un año
*
J.K. wrote love, and that's the solution. You're looking for stuff that doesn't exist...
tototo19 posted hace más de un año
hollywoodluv said:
i thought it was amor to because in the 5th movie at the end harry says he feels sorry for voldermort because he has never known love
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
Harry_98_Potter said:
No I dont think it was. He didnt keep the elder wand, so it couldnt be the power, plus Voldemort is the one that really used the wand, Harry only repaird his Pheonix wand.

select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
Power???????? I thought we were talking about secret, not power.
PotterFanatic posted hace más de un año
harrypotter91 said:
I don't think so because amor is the power Harry had that Voldemort didn't. Harry wouldn't have won without Ron and Hermione to help him find and destroy the Horcruxes. Harry had something worth fighting for. Not only his life but his friend's lives too. It takes real courage and amor to face death like when he is prepared to die for everyone at Hogwarts and in the whole world when he goes into the forest.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
Irina92 said:
i think that the profecy talks bout the power that harry has the certain time that voldemort marked him... remember?`The one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord approaches. born to those who have thrice defied him, born as the seventh mes dies . and the Dark Lord will mark him as his equal, but he will have power the Dark Lord knows not . and either must die at the hand of the other for neither can live while the other survives . the one with the power to vanquish the Dark Lord will be born as the seventh mes dies .'
and, besides, as dumbledore dicho (i know he's not infallible but everyone would understand this if they'd thought bout wat the 5th book sais!) the profecy doesn't matter! it mattered only coz of voldemort who did excactly wat trelawny said! so the profecy could change, depending on our knowledge... at first we knew bout love, now bout elder wand, then we'll think bout sth else to add into the foreseen things! so if the profecy is eventually important, i believe wat i dicho above, that it was bout the power harry had the time that voldemort aimed him...
that's wat i think!:))
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
paiges2 said:
elder wand ownership
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
EverybodyLies said:
dumbledore is never wrong.
soooo
no.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
volleyblue13 said:
Why can it not mean both? If Harry didn't have love, he would've never made it through all of those years, and if he didn't have the Elder Wand's ownership, he wouldn't have been able to kill Voldemort! It was both! Plus, his bravery, courage, and intelligence!

When the prophecy states that "He'll have power the Dark Lork knows not" it doesn't have to mean just ONE thing, the word "power" could be a combination of things! For example, if some person that wasn't as strong and Valiente as Harry (and as loving), then he probably wouldn't have the strength to finish off Voldemort, because he would be unable to face him. They also wouldn't be able to sacrifice themselves for the people they amor (even though Harry didn't die, the meaning was still there).

I believe that the prophecy reffered to Harry's ability, love, and the Elder Wand! That gives him "power the Dark Lord knows not", because Voldemort thought Harry was "weak", that amor wasn't important, and that HE was the master of the Elder Wand!
select as best answer
 Why can it not mean both? If Harry didn't have love, he would've never made it through all of those years, and if he didn't have the Elder Wand's ownership, he wouldn't have been able to kill Voldemort! It was both! Plus, his bravery, courage, and intelligence! When the prophecy states that "He'll have power the Dark Lork knows not" it doesn't have to mean just ONE thing, the word "power" could be a combination of things! For example, if some person that wasn't as strong and Valiente as Harry (and as loving), then he probably wouldn't have the strength to finish off Voldemort, because he would be unable to face him. They also wouldn't be able to sacrifice themselves for the people they amor (even though Harry didn't die, the meaning was still there). I believe that the prophecy reffered to Harry's ability, love, and the Elder Wand! That gives him "power the Dark Lord knows not", because Voldemort thought Harry was "weak", that amor wasn't important, and that HE was the master of the Elder Wand!
posted hace más de un año 
next question »