responde esta pregunta

harry potter Pregunta

Do tu believe many of the characters would not have died if Dumblebor had been más forth coming with information if so: Who and Why?

 frostydragon posted hace más de un año
next question »

harry potter  mejor respuesta

KateKicksAss said:
I don't know about MANY, BUT I do believe that Sirius wouldn't have o would have been much less likely to die if Dumbledore had shared más with Harry in OOTP. If Dumbledore had AT LEAST filled Harry in on the teeny little fact that Voldemort was able to manipulate and see into his mind, he would have been much less likely to believe the vision that Voldemort sent him, which led him and his friends to the Department of Mysteries.

Also, this is sort of unrelated, XD, but I was also always wondering in in GOF, if Dumbledore KNEW that Voldy was likely going to make a reappearance (Snape & Karkaroff's Dark Marks becoming clearer), then why didn't they try and do anything about it, and just (to quote the movie) "let the evens unfold"????
select as best answer
 I don't know about MANY, BUT I do believe that Sirius wouldn't have o would have been much less likely to die if Dumbledore had shared más with Harry in OOTP. If Dumbledore had AT LEAST filled Harry in on the teeny little fact that Voldemort was able to manipulate and see into his mind, he would have been much less likely to believe the vision that Voldemort sent him, which led him and his friends to the Department of Mysteries. Also, this is sort of unrelated, XD, but I was also always wondering in in GOF, if Dumbledore KNEW that Voldy was likely going to make a reappearance (Snape & Karkaroff's Dark Marks becoming clearer), then why didn't they try and do anything about it, and just (to quote the movie) "let the evens unfold"????
posted hace más de un año 
*
i'm agree with u !! Poor Sirius !!
ReibyKathBlack posted hace más de un año
*
Snape did point this out to minister and it was dismissed. sounds like our goverment. deni ability.
frostydragon posted hace más de un año
*
Poop
Love4Hermione posted hace más de un año
*
That's an interesting point...
Sasume posted hace más de un año
next question »

Respuestas

bri-marie said:
I think if Dumbledore had been más open and honest with Harry, and told him about the connection in book 5, Harry would have hesitated before running off to the ministry (perhaps he would have told him Sirius was fine, o remembered the mirror, o even used the floo again).

I think if Dumbledore had been upfront about how the Elderwand worked, Severus could have been más prepared.

And, technically, I think if Dumbledore had been más open and honest about what he thought Voldemort was doing (creating something to make him immortal) he could have had a lot más help collecting those memories. That would have saved a lot of people.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
Dumbledore couldn't tell Harry about the Elder wand, for fear of power taking over. However, I agree that Sirius' death could have been avoided :(
SiriusSeverus posted hace más de un año
*
I didn't say anything about Dumbledore explaining anything about the Elder wand to Harry. I meant if Dumbledore had explained to Severus that Voldemort would think that Severus had it because he killed Dumbledore, than Severus would have had a better chance.
bri-marie posted hace más de un año
*
Thank tu for your responce I agree totally. After Albus saw Sirius' death was needless he should have learned that secrets get people dead.
frostydragon posted hace más de un año
*
Even just letting Snape know that tu didn
nene72 posted hace más de un año
ABDCFan- said:
No. I don't believe this. Even if Dumbledore had been más forth coming with the information, that would probably have meant that Voldemort would feel the need to rise up faster, and this may lead to más deaths. So, no, I don't believe that many of the characters wouldn't have died if Dumbledore had been más forth coming.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
Rise faster, that's a good point.
HecateA posted hace más de un año
T_ballack said:
i absolutely don't think there would have been less death had dumbledore been más forth coming about information if anything there would have been más deaths cause voldemort was a great legilimence and any information about him known por anyone would have made him go on a killing spree. Concerning sirius's death dumledore told snape to teach harry occulumency which was to stop external penetration on the mind and snape told harry indirectly warning him that the dark lord used legilimency to lay bare people's mind plant imágenes and eventually drive them mad knowing this harry still went to the ministry to save sirius even when hermione warned him that it might be a trap from voldemort and concerning using floo powder harry did use it and voldemort being the genius that he was placed kreacher there to lie and confirmar his fears and about the two-way mirror harry completely forgot about it because the instant sirius gave him he had no intention of using it so as not to get sirius caught por umbridge o the ministry it had nothing to do with dumbledore giving him information and the major reason harry went there was because i think u will agree with me that harry has a hero complex. About the elder wand and dumbledore telling snape it wouldn't have made a difference except distract snape from what he needed to do b'cos of the fear of death and even if he did have forewarning he could never have escaped voldemort and would still have been killed. I firmly believe dumbledor gave enough information to ensure that voldemort was defeated.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
next question »