responde esta pregunta

harry potter vs crepúsculo Pregunta

Harry Potter fans: What do tu like least about Twilight? Twilight fans: What do tu like least about Harry Potter?

My personal least favourite thing about Tw*l*ght is how anti-feminism it is. Edward abuses her, and she doesn't even care! She is completely dependent on him and can't walk away. He takes advantage of her love.
*
Agreed, also how everything seems to revolve around Bella like there sin't a world outside. :)
mimifaith posted hace más de un año
*
i segundo that
ginny_potter_97 posted hace más de un año
*
^^^Third!
traceyhp posted hace más de un año
*
agreed
haleylynnr1 posted hace más de un año
 MissKnowItAll posted hace más de un año
next question »

harry potter vs crepúsculo  mejor respuesta

ToyletGnome said:
I agree.
- sexism
- abuse
- lack of plot
- boring dialogue
- rape of thesauruses
- rape of mythical creatures
- paedophilia
- necrophilia
- bestiality
- unrealistic relationships
- stereotypes and lack of character development
- poor villains
- shallow behaviour
- bad grammar
- egotistical Smeyer
- bad clichés
- bad casting (in the movies)
- constant descriptions of Edward's extreme beauty
etc.

I could go on for years.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
tu pretty much summed it up.
ThatDamnLlama posted hace más de un año
*
what do u mean? twilight saga o harry potter?
kilie posted hace más de un año
*
WOW.Too true.
kwlski4ever posted hace más de un año
next question »

Respuestas

kilie said:
im a TWWILIGHT SAGA fan ok i dont like harry potter as much as i amor TWILIGHT SAGA i do like harry potter but yeah i just hate magic
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
That answer doesn't make much sense. Do tu like HP o not? Yes o no?
MissKnowItAll posted hace más de un año
*
Its not a saga
ginny_potter_97 posted hace más de un año
*
I don't like magic either.
cassie-1-2-3 posted hace más de un año
EmilyWeasley said:
Maybe I'm wrong... but I always thought this club was about people that loved Twilight AND Harry Potter, and they would discuss it - o at least be civilized. If it's just about people criticizing the characters/author/actors of the series they don't like, then I don't know what am I doing here. Maybe I should just stop coming to this club.
Oh and just for the record, Bella isn't a weak, anti-femininsm character. She wants Edward and fights to stay with him, even when he wants to push her way. Bella is actually a strong character - if she wasn't she would have ran away when she figured out Edward's a vampire and she wouldn't have faced the Volturi if she didn't have guts. Edward doesn't take advantage of her love, he PROTECTS her. Jacob, Mike, Eric o any other guy would have done the same thing he did if they could. And of course everything revolves around Bella, we read HER POV! It's her life we follow. Besides we don't see her life 24/7, we see some of her life not every single thought she has during months.
Oh, and wizards don't suck.
But to answer tu question.
What I like the least about Twilight: stereotypes (Rosalie is your typical blonde, Jessica and Lauren are your typical b******), slow passing and lack of development of minor characters.
What I like the least about HP: Slow passing, long unnecessary descriptions, Harry's selfishness (even though he is a hero and cares about other people, his closest friends and the ones that care about him the most, Ron and Hermione, he is conviced they are fine on their one he doesn't even bother to actually worry about them. Not much) and of course, the misceláneo characters that literally appear out of nowhere and are in every single chapter of the book. Then they are never mentioned again.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
No. The club you're looking for is the CAT spot. Bella is very anti-feminism. There's alot of reasons for this- too many to explain in this comment. I'm sure that if tu loo around the spot you'll find some explanation.But I will answer the points tu put forward. Bella is loyal, but más in a perrito, cachorro love, sickening kind of way. She is dependent on Edward, not in amor with him, Not running away when tu meet a vampire is not 'strong' o 'brave', it is stupid. I haven't read New Moon in a while, so I can't answer the bit about the Volturi properly- I'd need to read the chapter etc. In my opinion, he takes advantage of her love, o her dependency, which I explained earlier. Maybe Mike o Jacob would have done the same, but that doesn't make it right. I haven't wrote about everything revolving around Bella, so I can't respond. Harry does care a lot about Ron and Hermione- this is very clear in the books. Anyway, this is getting very long winded, so I'll stop.
MissKnowItAll posted hace más de un año
*
I disagree: I don't think Bella is anti-feminism. Just like I don't agree that Bella acted stupidly por not tunning away from Edward when she figured out he's a vampire, I think that's bravery (I would have run). I disagree also with tu when tu dicho Edward takes advantage of her love, at least, can't remember one scene in which it has happened (Jacob and Mike are far más selfish than he is). Also Harry cares about his friends, but the lack of worry with about safety shows how selfish he can be. There are libros in which he mentions them alot, and others in which he worries about everything but them.
EmilyWeasley posted hace más de un año
*
I disagree. Bella is very anti-feminism. She cannot surive without a man in her life. There is no paticular scene in which he takes advantage of her love- it's más than she is dependent on him, he knows it, and takes advantage of that. Again, just because Mike o Jacob would have done the same does not make it right. Any sensible person would have ran if they found out that the guy they liked was a vampire. There is a fine line between bravery and stupidity- Bella crossed it. It is not that Harry has a disregard for safety- but he has a need to be a hero, which leads to him doing the things he does.Harry may not have his friends at the parte superior, arriba of the worry lista all the time- but they are constantly there. In every fight o battle, he worries.
MissKnowItAll posted hace más de un año
SEEKER6 said:
Just a picture i found: Small argu,emt. Just an opinion! The picture says:
First of all- Harry Potter isn't just a childish bedtime story. Nor is it shallow. A story based off a single dream has no depth. Twilight fans will never know what kind of man James was before he turned vampire. Rowling, however, spent 15 año planning every little detail. She created a world within our own for her own witched and wizards. She has based their heritage off of real mythologhy and history. Their spells are in a dead language and they have organized governments with strict laws. She has followed her characters stories from childhood to Graduation and many times to their deaths. One of the best things about this series is that tu can study these intricate details. The twilight fans can only really argue about who bella will marry.In harry Potter, there are arguments over everything from snape's loyalty , to the cryptic meaning of Trelawney's prophesies, to Petty-ship wars. In twilight, very few people ask the questions: (read the picture). To Potter fans These are common everyday questions. like an amusing childhood Fairytale, meyer's "saga" is to be taken for face value; Delving Deep within will display its undesirable flaws. The mere FACT that Harry Potter makes tu think, makes tu questinos rowling and causes tu to come up with creative theories PROVES ITS SUPERIORITY! (ALL OPINIONS!)
select as best answer
 Just a picture i found: Small argu,emt. Just an opinion! The picture says: First of all- Harry Potter isn't just a childish bedtime story. Nor is it shallow. A story based off a single dream has no depth. Twilight fans will never know what kind of man James was before he turned vampire. Rowling, however, spent 15 año planning every little detail. She created a world within our own for her own witched and wizards. She has based their heritage off of real mythologhy and history. Their spells are in a dead language and they have organized governments with strict laws. She has followed her characters stories from childhood to Graduation and many times to their deaths. One of the best things about this series is that tu can study these intricate details. The twilight fans can only really argue about who bella will marry.In harry Potter, there are arguments over everything from snape's loyalty , to the cryptic meaning of Trelawney's prophesies, to Petty-ship wars. In twilight, very few people ask the questions: (read the picture). To Potter fans These are common everyday questions. like an amusing childhood Fairytale, meyer's "saga" is to be taken for face value; Delving Deep within will display its undesirable flaws. The mere FACT that Harry Potter makes tu think, makes tu questinos rowling and causes tu to come up with creative theories PROVES ITS SUPERIORITY! (ALL OPINIONS!)
posted hace más de un año 
LoopyLuna96 said:
Twilight: No plot, some annoying fangirls(not all, to be fair), Bella Swan, Edward Cullen, Edward's controlling personality, the whole thing is anti-feminist
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
ok if u dont like it GET OFF
kilie posted hace más de un año
*
It's fine.
MissKnowItAll posted hace más de un año
*
Sorry I got a bit angry. But LoonyLuna's my little sister, and I don't like people being, tu know, like that to her.
MissKnowItAll posted hace más de un año
bamagirl5899 said:
well everything revolves around harry oh and twilight is about the cullen family not just bella read the book sometime b4 u make a comment
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
We already DID that and , oh , BTW , this pregunta wasn't just aboout Tiwilght. It's about both sides !!!
kwlski4ever posted hace más de un año
*
It Twilight, it really does revolve all around Bella (and Edward, I guess). Harry Potter has subplots, which allow us to enjoy several minor stories within one major story.
ToyletGnome posted hace más de un año
*
Jezz, tu can't just assume that HP enamorados don't read Tw*l*ght, when did we ever say that it was only about Bella?
boolander25 posted hace más de un año
*
Well, no, everything doesn't revolve around Harry. There's Ron, Hermione, and like "ToyletGnome" pointed out, subplots and background stories about other characters that manages to fit with the main plot without going too off topic and confusing. So, no, everything is not just about Harry in the books.
MrsSiriusB posted hace más de un año
BellaBlackL said:
I hate Twilight because I'm not in it :(. And that stupid "Bella" girl estola my name.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
Bella cisne sucks.
kwlski4ever posted hace más de un año
*
I know! And she thinks she can steal my name!
BellaBlackL posted hace más de un año
*
bella calm down u can always avada kedavra her sorry little butt
ginny_potter_97 posted hace más de un año
*
Yeah, yay!
BellaBlackL posted hace más de un año
zanesaaomgfan said:
In what way does Edward abuse Bella? Do tu know theres something called protection! And thats what hes doing, therefore she doesn't care.

I HATE wizards. Its stupid spells and magic! WTF??

Another thing I hate, the fact that it took me a whole 6th grade año to read ONE book(Order of the Pheonix o something)and I lost the book contest. I almost got held back. :(

I had to read a book over the summer. And do a stinking 3 reports! >:( (Thanks to Harry Potter Crap)

Another thing, I got a one in lectura and found out the book wasn't for my level. So I had trouble lectura because I was lectura HARRY POOPER! >:(

(I'm still mad)
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
I couldn't even take a foregien lanuguage until March.
zanesaaomgfan posted hace más de un año
*
Ahhh, I'm the exact same way. I hate any book I'm forced to read. At least tu seem to have mellowed out over the past año :D
AllyAM posted hace más de un año
*
Yeah. :3
zanesaaomgfan posted hace más de un año
ginny_potter_97 said:
heres whatg i think. it is in picture form so the twilight fans can understand it
select as best answer
 heres whatg i think. it is in picture form so the twilight fans can understand it
posted hace más de un año 
*
lol
BellaBlackL posted hace más de un año
*
Exactly
MissKnowItAll posted hace más de un año
*
and? her opinion is still valid, those dont expire
HecateA posted hace más de un año
livibba said:
Well I like both Harry potter and the twilight saga but if I have to pick something I didn't like I would say haw bella led Jacob on and once Edward was back in in picture she left Jacob at the drop of a hat but still expects Jacob to stay in her life and instead of actuación all hole in the corazón and jumping off that cliff in la push she should have just moved on with her life I mean ok I totally get the first loves are the hardest ones to recover from and you'll always amor that first amor no matter what but if she had just moved on with her life she would be a better and stronger person in the long run
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
traceyhp said:
I also hate the excessive amount of plot holes in the libros with everything that Bella does in the name and for the amor of 'Edward Cullen". :\
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
next question »