responde esta pregunta

harry potter vs crepúsculo Pregunta

Right... coming from a HP fan... aren't we being a little bit hypocritical?

Well we do say "you Twilight fans are so over the top. tu keep saying bad things about HP."

When we later say
"Twilight is a horrible book. It has no plot and Stephanie Meyer is a terrible writer."

:/

I just thought we say things like this and it just seems sorta hypocritical and mean. We are rude on Twilight. It's true, even if what we say is sorta true. But there's fact and opinion . For example::

Henry VIII married six times -- Fact
Elizabeth I was a beautiful queen -- Opinion.

I think we need to not say so many horrible things and just stick to the debating skills. It's what I've been doing recently.
*
Stop the peace & reasoning.
Yarrgh posted hace más de un año
*
i agree with Yarrgh
lokhart posted hace más de un año
*
i'm not trying to reason, tu know. I take back what I've dicho seeing as there are twilighters that think they are better now I publicado this :( the shame
1-2vampire posted hace más de un año
 1-2vampire posted hace más de un año
next question »

harry potter vs crepúsculo  mejor respuesta

Persephone713 said:
I think Twilight fans are just as guilty as being mean on this site as Harry Potter fans are. But I have yet to encounter a Harry Potter fan who goes so low as to insult the other persons icono because they dont like Twilight. See we may be mean but alot of it is because there are alot of Twilight fans that are very immature. And then in the pregunta area, there have been times when posts from twilight fans have been publicado that are unreadable o say things like" who would like harry potter Stephanie Meyer is way better writer than JO Rowling." And when we ask WHY tu guys like the series we get the reply " because Edward is hot". I rest my case.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
WOOT! Best answer :)
LilRavenclaw95 posted hace más de un año
*
Yes, precisely. But we should not stoop to their level in any case, no matter how much they get on our nerves.
LadyLilith posted hace más de un año
*
yeah i know but we tell them to stop being mean and then we be mean back to them. I know where you're coming from, but it's a debate! Not who is ruder HP fans o Twilight fans?
1-2vampire posted hace más de un año
next question »

Respuestas

VampiresRevenge said:
I'm not an Anti, but I am a Harry Potter fan and I'd like to say that I agree with you. I see it all of the time in the spot from both sides. I can't understand why some people think that they are allowed to say something, but when someone says it to them, they get offended and call the person mean. And this spot is supposed to be a debate spot after all, and not a "call the other side the worst names tu can while also degrading whatever they are a fan of," which is what this spot seemed to have transformed into.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
Voted best answer. :) I agree totally.
LadyLilith posted hace más de un año
*
Thanks! :)
VampiresRevenge posted hace más de un año
chagrin91 said:
OMG finally i meet a honest and really nice HP fan thank tu 1-2vampire.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
EYBanuelos said:
Actually, there has been HP fans that do give facts when it comes to criticizing Twilight. But I have to admmit that sometimes we get really childish and start saying stuff like "Twilight sucks" without giving any proof on why it does.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
sapherequeen said:
I agree 100%.

It's actually one of the things that pisses me off about SOME Twilight haters lately.

I also notice that some Antis throw insults at the fans of Twilight here and there, even though most of them criticize the fans for not respecting their opinions.

I mean, c'mon now!

Anyways, yes, I agree.

I'm absolutely fine with anyone with opinions that are different from mine, and I know a lot of awesome people who dislike Twilight :)

But how about we just cut the insults, and focus and stick to simple debates, like tu said? :)
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
Wounded-Soul said:
Well,...we can por hypocrites at times...but I think we cant really help ourselves....It's just that- no offence to any twilight fans- We can find so many problems with the books...and it's hard not to mention that so much....but yeah, I agree...we Harry Potter fans could stop bashing Twilight so much...
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
lokhart said:
tu are correct we should not be so over the parte superior, arriba hypocritical person.
psst... have tu developed a liking towards twilight saga
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
Just because she's addressing a problem with the spot doesn't mean she likes Twilight now. She may, but I'm just saying.
LadyLilith posted hace más de un año
*
there is a possibilty
lokhart posted hace más de un año
*
nah i don't in fact I really hate twilight I can't go into Clairs Accessories anymore (THEY HAVE A RACK OF TWILIGHT STUFF! :( )
1-2vampire posted hace más de un año
eli218 said:
Well i agree that we can be mean sometimes, but the thing is that we say bad things about the libros and not to the fans, unlike Twihards that say really mean things to us like "f**k off" o "dig a hole and jump in it" i mean this is a discusion about the libros and movies, there´s no need to say that.....
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
LilRavenclaw95 said:
I agree, but we insult the book itself. Never before have I insulted someone simply for liking Twilight, which seems to be what some people do. And yes, I say awful things about Twilight, but I always back them up. I don't say "Twilight sucks, end of story", and honestly, most of the HP fans actually do seem to use reason. It's the ones who don't that make us all look bad. I admit, sometimes I'm bad about it (I lose my temper and get an attitude) too. But I really try to be fair.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
agreed,
1-2vampire posted hace más de un año
miyaismykitty said:
well look at it this way, they are probabaly just as big hippocrites as we are lol, but it does matter cuz we are both to prideful of our books
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
HOU0007 said:
Im a HP fan & a Twilight saga fan as well. I agree that sometimes we take it a little bit to fare. But some of us think that's fine. As long as nobody starts crying that peoples arn't being nice. Than I think it's ok.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
Abilei said:
I think both sides are just as equal at fault. No one wants their book/movie bashed on and so when someone from an apposing team says o goes against their book/movie they attack. It's a cycle actually.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
MidnaTikal8223 said:
Well, coming from a fan of both, both sides are unforgiving, rude, and sometimes some of the things are just plain mean.I like both, so I don't get into this war.

Why can't both sides just stop and admit that both are a legacy that is amazing and never will we forget either Harry Potter, o Twilight?
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
Actually, the legacy thing is the biggest debate, in my opinion. Look at how far Harry Potter has come, versus Twilight. Theme park is opening this spring (I want to go SO BAD), and there's even a Harry Potter DAY. Not to mention gross income for each book (and movie).... Sorry, just had to put that out there.
LilRavenclaw95 posted hace más de un año
*
Well, Harry Potter has been out longer, too(Personally, I lean tword this side)
MidnaTikal8223 posted hace más de un año
*
I have to agree with LilRavenclaw95, I don't think Twilight will be AS appreciated por the World than HP. :)
1-2vampire posted hace más de un año
LadyLilith said:
I agree completely. I've been trying to put más friendly stuff on this spot, to try and get everyone to kind of cooperate and enjoy talking to each other. And I've been trying to be nicer, and stop getting into any fights, and stop any that I see. ^^,, I don't know if the fighting will ever stop, but I think we're a work in progress.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
I agree, who likes being mean. But if they are going to be rediculous to us- like picking on iconos for example, how can tu not respond.
Persephone713 posted hace más de un año
*
Ha...oh yeah. I can't help but wig out sometimes on people like that.
LadyLilith posted hace más de un año
MCRTS said:
Well, Harry Potter fans actually jump in the deep end of the lake and read Twilight. Most of us compare Twilight critically, from what we've read in the books. However, SOME (I repeat: SOME) Twilight fans do not read Harry Potter, and they want to compare it base on the little they know. And they would say something like "harry potter sux!!1! its such a boring book! twilight is 1000000000X betta! tiwlight 4eva!11!!" (It's an actual quote too)
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
*
i understand, I have a friend who says Twilight is better when she has read the Twilight libros but only seen the HP movies.
1-2vampire posted hace más de un año
woofbark said:
I think there is really only one major problem on this spot-fans that generalize and jump to conclusions.
One Twilight fan spells every word wrong: HP FAN: All Twilight fans must be crazy!
One HP fan thinks Twilight fans are crazy-TWILGHT FAN: Hp fans all think we are insane!
These conclusions pit us against each other. I might have dicho this before, but I think we should start thinking of fans as individuals instead of just one big group.
select as best answer
posted hace más de un año 
next question »