Well, I prefer this dude, most of all, because I think Mr. Schuester is kinda creepy...

I would have never thought I would have picked him, but after last night's episode, I am really, really not like Will or Wemma for that matter! Will acted like an immature, high school student who was trying to establish some what? competition? Emma is happy with Carl, and we can all see that he is good for him, so doing the whole Rocky Horror show just to one up himself on Carl that was really low!
I love the Will from season 1, who put his students above everything else, who truly believed in the magic of the arts, not this selfish Will! I really hope you redeem yourself Mr. Shue cause I miss the old you!

And for the completely difficult-to-deal problem of phobia that Emma suffers, Will is not helping at all... and I don't think he puts his students for first, he left the club twice and then he rejoined!!! (WTF? >_<)...

this is really unfair. I cant vote bettween Uncle Jesse and Matts dancing :(

I don't like Carl with Emma, i think she should be with Will, but as a person i like Carl more.

As for now, Carl > Will.

but this is hard because after "whatever happened to Saturday night?", i think i love Carl, but i love Will too and i've loved him for longer so i'm going to pick him, but quite frankly Will's creepy behavior needs to stop.

Will annoys me so much lately and Carl seems to be pretty cool.

I think Carl is a great character and I loved his singing voice.

Will started to be a little creepy. Carl is better a lot ways

I miss season 1 Will. This new Will pisses me off.

At the moment, Carl!

Carl's great, I'm starting not to like Will that much

^^^ same.

Though I'm not too crazy about Will this season, and I quite like Carl. I KNOW Mr. Shue will redeem himself in my heart though and I adore Wemma.

deffo

Will we truly need because he's the head of the Glee club! But Carl added to the show is a really good thing not only for Emma but for a kina war between Will & Carl for the show!

I always disliked Will, and on this season it got worst..

i always disliked will AND CARL SO THIS WAS HARD BUT CARL SUCS MORE

CARL SUCKS! HE STOLE EMMA!!