Totally! Because Luke knew that Brooke sleeping with Chris meant nothing but Lucas kissing Peyton always meant something

^^^^i dont know...i dont think the kiss meant anything to lucas!! i think the fact that lucas KEPT the kiss from brooke...that he didnt finally tell her until he THOUGHT she knew!! i think thats what MADE brooke think that the kiss did mean something!!

but if you add that with the fact that brooke just found out that peyton was supposedly 'in' love with lucas is what shattered her heart!!

i think after that point brooke thought that the 'triangle from hell' was gonna happen again, that lucas was gonna choose peyton over her again...so before that could happen brooke broke up with lucas to save what little of her heart that wasnt broken!! but that didn't really work out cause that little part of her heart that was left STILL got broken in the end!!

the only 2 things that are different about these situations are the outcomes...after what brooke did, lucas still got brooke in the end; at least until 322...but after the whole leyton kiss, brooke didnt get lucas in the end, she got to be alone!! so by considerin the after effects, yes brooke was the more heart broken one...but if you just look at these 2 situations all on there own, i would say that they were equally heart broken!!

This was hard, cause i think both were shocked, surpised and really hurt by this. but i had to go with Brooke cause shes been through this kinda shit before.

She slept with Chris , because she was drunk and it was her first time like that . Luke did it AGAIN !!:/