After tonight's shocker, and remembering astonishing results in the past, I realize that I may have very different criteria for who should win "American Idol" than the majority of voters. So I asked three separate pick questions, for the primary, secondary and tertiary factors you consider when you vote for a contestant. If there was a way to create a pick that let you choose multiple answers, I'd do it. But as we can't, I made three separate ones. They're here:

link
link
link

When answering these questions, please make sure to choose different picks for each. Thanks!